"The NHS will last as long as there are folk left with the faith to fight for it"
Aneurin Bevan

Wednesday 14 December 2011

Diabetes Audit

There is something a bit odd about the shock news released today that people who have a serious (but controllable) medical condition are not expected to live as long as people without it. As per usual, the BBC are reporting the news as if no one has ever been aware of it, but I came to the conclusion a year ago that the BBC have an agenda to broadcast as many articles as possible that puts the NHS in a poor light. (Not surprising really, since that is the agenda of the Department of Health and the BBC seems to be the biggest consumer of churnalism at the moment.)

Let's look at what the BBC are saying.

"Up to 24,000 deaths from diabetes could be avoided in England each year, if patients and doctors better managed the condition, a report concludes."
Let's look at the statistics. Diabetes UK say that there are 2.9 million people with diabetes (type 1 and type 2) or 4.45% of the UK population. They also say that 90% of diabetics have type 2 diabetes.

ONS says that in 2010 there were 493,000 deaths in the UK. Out of a population of 62 million that means slightly under 0.8% of the population. ONS provides detailed tables giving the cause of death.


The figures says that in 2010, 5,223 people died from diabetes. When just over five thousand people die from diabetes a year, the BBC says that almost five times more deaths can be avoided. How? Perhaps this statement from the BBC article explains why:

"Around 70-75,000 diabetic patients die every year." 
This is not the number of people who die from diabetes, this is the number of diabetics who die. Such people could be dying of cancer, stroke or heart attacks; in other words the same things that everyone else dies of. Diabetes may well exasperate these conditions, but that is not the same as dying from diabetes; ONS says so.

The BBC says:


For patients with Type 1, the risk of dying was 2.6 times higher than it was for the general population. With Type 2, the risk was 1.6 times higher.
The figures that I gave above from Diabetes UK about diabetes mortality are also in a PDF report on their website called Diabetes in the UK 2010: Key statistics on diabetes. In a section called Life expectancy and mortality it has these statistics:
More than one in ten (11.6 per cent) deaths among 20 to 79-year-olds in England can be attributed to diabetes. If current trends continue, one in eight (12.2 per cent) deaths among 20 to 79-year-olds will be attributable to the condition by 2010.
Life expectancy is reduced, on average, by:
– more than 20 years in people with Type 1 diabetes
– up to 10 years in people with Type 2 diabetes
Note the date: 2010. In fact, the figures for the reduction in life expectancy comes from a Department of Health report dated 2001. The 11.6% figure comes from a report in 2008. In other words, none of this is new.

Then the BBC report this:

The Department of Health in England said shocking variations in care and an unacceptable death toll were evident. 
Where did they get this impression from? Variation in the treatment of diabetes can be obtained from the Quality Outcomes Framework, that the Department of Health have been collecting since 2004.

Eh? They have known since 2004 that there were shocking variations and have done nothing about it? Are the Department of Health that incompetent?

The BBC report is churnalism of the press release on the NHS Information Centre. The news is not shocking, it is well known, the NHS IC merely have produced a report about something we all knew anyway. Perhaps the most interesting part of the NHS IC report is this:

"There is a strong link between deprivation and increased mortality rates. Among under-65s with diabetes; the number of deaths among people from the most deprived backgrounds is double that of those from the least deprived backgrounds."
This re-states something that was in the Diabetes Audit (pdf) from last year:
"In those aged 70 years and over, similar numbers of Q1 (12.1 per cent) and Q5 (14.8 per cent) have Type 2 diabetes, but under the age of 55 Type 2 diabetes is more than twice as common in Q5 (3.0 per cent) as Q1 (1.3 per cent). This may reflect lifestyle differences in exercise, diet and weight."
Q1 is the least deprived quintile of the population, Q5 is the most deprived. There is a clear message here: deprivation causes type 2 diabetes. The BBC didn't report that, did they?

18 comments:

  1. It gets worse. The press release (and BBC) quote the relative risks of dying ("Women between the ages of 15 and 34 with Type 1 diabetes were nine times more likely to die than other women of the same age. Men in the same age group were four times more likely to die if they had the condition."), without giving the absolute risks? Without knowing the absolute risks, the relative risks are, at best, meaningless. At worst they are highly misleading.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I have type 2 diabetes. I have a yearly check up with blood tests, an hour with the diabetic nurse where she goes through my care bit by bit. I am on aspirin and statins as a preventative measure. I cannot fault the care given to me by my GP practice. I could not get better anywhere in the world. Stop knocking the NHS and give it the credit it is due. How many lives have been saved thanks to the NHS? Oh wait, thats not important is it.... just how much it can be belittled

    ReplyDelete
  3. Interesting post, but I disagree with most points. The ONS data is incomplete as diabetes rarely recorded on death certificates. Just because previous reports concluded the same findings does not invalidate reporting of a contemporaneous study. And of course the DH has been trying to improve this since 2004 but it is a difficult situation to improve. However, the BBC cud have been clearer about distinction between dying with and from diabetes, tho.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Furthermore, I think saying 'deprivation causes type 2 diabetes' is unsubstantiated by the evidence provided, and in any case over-simplifies the issue. I am a journalist, by the way, so I do consider these concerns about 'churnalism' etc carefully to avoid falling into that trap.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Slightly off-topic and possible anecdotal, but I remember around the time leading up to the UK smoking ban, some misrepresentation of 'deaths from smoking-related diseases' where anyone who died of (eg) lung cancer - whether or not they ever smoked - was classed as dying from a 'smoking-related disease'.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Good analysis, its interesting to know the facts. Visit the Best Diabetes Hospital in Coimbatore

    ReplyDelete
  7. Thanks for sharing such informative content with us... Keep posting! You can also check out our recent blog post regarding risk factors for diabetes on our site.

    ReplyDelete
  8. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  9. The most effective and reliable solution to treat erectile dysfunction (ED) can be found in Vidalista 20 mg capsules. Sexual disorders include erectile dysfunction(ED), male impotence, etc. Vidalista 20mg as well as Cialis both contain the same active ingredient, generic Tadalafil and both medications are prescribed with the same reason, which seeks to relieve ED Vidalista 20 mg. If you consume any product that contains grapefruit, don't make use of the Vidalista 20 pills because grape juice can affect the effectiveness of the drugs. Aurogra 100, Vega 100

    ReplyDelete
  10. What's the cause of this phenomenon? Men would dismiss it as women's liberation, or the rise of the feminist movement that is hardcore medicine is Cenforce 50. But, many intelligent people would describe it an awakening for women. Women today are not the doormats they were fifty years ago. They are conscious of their wants, needs and wants. They are no longer a believer in an "give-give" relationship, rather they promote mutually advantageous "give and take" relationships.

    Alternative ED Treatment Medicine is Here
    tadalista 10
    malegra 100
    Suhagra 100

    ReplyDelete
  11. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Buy Cenforce 25mg ( Sildenafil ) In Best Price – Cenforcepills
    About Cenforce 25mg
    Cenforce 25 aides treat Erectile Brokenness in men. It expands the bloodstream to the phallus locale. It gets an erection and supports it.
    Cenforce 100mg is a class of prescriptions called a phosphodiesterase type 5 (PDE 5) inhibitor.
    Cenforce 25mg Producer
    The assembly of Cenforce 25mg is finished by Centurion Research facilities.
    Featuring realities about Cenforce 25mg
    Cenforce 25mg prescription containing dynamic fixing Sildenafil is open under the brand name and conventional medication name Viagra.
    This prescription comes and three structures, i.e., an oral medicine fluid or Suspension and infusion structure, just recommended by the specialist as per your erectile brokenness condition.
    Why sildenafil Cenforce 25mg is utilized?
    Cenforce 25mg medicine is ace and treats aspiratory blood vessel hypertension and erectile brokenness. This conventional oral prescription is available for the two circumstances Under the Viagra brand name.
    Assuming you take this medicine to treat erectile brokenness, it assists with achieving and keeping up with erection without any problem.
    Cenforce 25mg measurements:
    If you start the treatment with Cenforce 25mg prescription, it is the most extreme measurement strength for your underlying treatment. Nonetheless, before beginning the treatment, it is prudent to counsel the specialist and assess the legitimate condition. As indicated by your condition specialist will recommend the dose, and you should follow it likewise without modifying them.
    What Is Bluemen 100 Mg?
    bluemen 100 is a medicine that can give the best proportion of political choice in a man encountering erectile brokenness. One of the principal parts of medication is that composite parts can give the best results to an individual encountering a sexual issue like erectile brokenness.
    Bluemen 100 mg is a drug that has been arranged and made at the RSM Undertakings LLP office in Chandigarh for its general trading and selling.
    The medicine can give the main degrees of sexual satisfaction for an individual encountering a sexual issue who is wanting to satisfy the necessities of his assistant.
    What Is Begma 100 Mg?
    begma 100 is a medication that is utilized in the treatment of epilepsy. It is a prescription created during the 1950s and used to treat epilepsy. It's anything but a fix, however, a medicine can assist with controlling seizures.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Buy Cenforce 150 in chipset price Online – Cenforcepills
    What is Cenforce 150?
    Cenforce 150 is a medication that helps treat male weakness. It works by expanding the bloodstream to the penile region of the body. This helps men in getting and keeping an erection.
    Utilization of Cenforce 150 pills
    This medication treats erectile brokenness (ineptitude). Erectile brokenness is a sexual problem in guys who can't accomplish a sufficiently hard erection for sex.
    Capacity
    Get this medication far from dampness, heat, and direct light in a shut holder at room temperature.
    Keep out of youngsters' span. Try not to store terminated meds.
    Incidental effects
    Even though Cenforce 150 is protected to utilize, it makes specific side impacts, very much like some other drug. Normal aftereffects might include:
    Cerebral pain or unsteadiness
    • Flushing (warmth, redness, or shivery inclination)
    • Unusual vision
    • Acid reflux, queasiness, or annoyed stomach
    • Rest issues (sleep deprivation)
    • Muscle torment or back torment
    • Runny or stodgy nose

    What are Alvitra 40mg Tablets
    alvitra 40 is a prescription endorsed for the treatment of erectile brokenness in men. This medication is a creation of conventional Vardenafil which is its chief fixing known for improving the power in men to carry on with a blissful sexual life. The class of phosphodiesterase type 5 inhibitors incorporates Vardenafil which fills in as a protein inhibitor advancing erection among men. This medication is accessible in strong structures, i.e., tablets, and is the most secure as well as a supportive prescription to determine the issue of erectile brokenness. It works for practically every one of the men by the imprint of its quick activity and life span.

    IS SILDAMAX SAFE?
    Sildamax is a drug that is normally used to treat erectile brokenness or comparable weakness issues. It is made in India and cases contain a similar dynamic fixing as Viagra to be specific, Sildenafil Citrate, nonetheless, the item (which ordinarily arrives in a 100mg tablet) has not finished quality standard assessments for the lawful deal in the UK.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Buy Cenforce 120 (Sildenafil) Online – Cenforcepills
    What is Cenforce 120 (Sildenafil Citrate)?
    [url=https://www.cenforcepills.com/product/cenforce-120-mg/]Cenforce 120[/url] is a remedy-based drug for the treatment of Erectile Brokenness (ED) or feebleness in men.
    Sildenafil Citrate is the dynamic fixing present in the medication.
    Sildenafil treats barrenness by decreasing the working of Phosphodiesterase type-5 (PDE5), a normally happening compound in the penile locale.

    Utilizations of Cenforce 120
    • As referenced above, Cenforce 120 tablets treat Erectile Brokenness (barrenness).
    • ED is male sexual brokenness wherein men can't accomplish an erection firm enough for sexual activity.
    • This medication is a PDE 5 inhibitor that blocks the PDE 5 chemicals liable for penile laxity.
    • It further develops the bloodstream to the penile region by loosening up veins.
    • Note: This medication will just work on sexual excitement.

    Step-by-step instructions to take the Suhagra (Sildenafil Citrate and Duloxetine Hydrochloride):
    [url=https://www.cenforcepills.com/product/suhagra-tablet/]Suhagra[/url] portion ought to be taken at a proper time as coordinated by your primary care physician. Swallow the tablet with water without biting or pounding it. It is constantly encouraged to take it with food to stay away from stomach upset.

    Utilization of Super P Force
    • [url=https://www.cenforcepills.com/product/super-p-force/]Super P Force[/url] for treating Erectile Brokenness and Untimely Discharge in men.
    • It is otherwise called 'Barrenness,' this brokenness makes it hard to get or keep an erection while having intercourse.
    • This medication likewise treats PE. In this situation, men discharge before they expect while participate in sexual activity.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Buy Cenforce 120 (Sildenafil) Online – Cenforcepills
    What is Cenforce 120 (Sildenafil Citrate)?
    Cenforce 120 is a remedy-based drug for the treatment of Erectile Brokenness (ED) or feebleness in men.
    Sildenafil Citrate is the dynamic fixing present in the medication.
    Sildenafil treats barrenness by decreasing the working of Phosphodiesterase type-5 (PDE5), a normally happening compound in the penile locale.

    Utilizations of Cenforce 120
    • As referenced above, Cenforce 120 tablets treat Erectile Brokenness (barrenness).
    • ED is male sexual brokenness wherein men can't accomplish an erection firm enough for sexual activity.
    • This medication is a PDE 5 inhibitor that blocks the PDE 5 chemicals liable for penile laxity.
    • It further develops the bloodstream to the penile region by loosening up veins.
    • Note: This medication will just work on sexual excitement.

    Step-by-step instructions to take the Suhagra (Sildenafil Citrate and Duloxetine Hydrochloride):
    Suhagra portion ought to be taken at a proper time as coordinated by your primary care physician. Swallow the tablet with water without biting or pounding it. It is constantly encouraged to take it with food to stay away from stomach upset.

    Utilization of Super P Force
    Super P Force for treating Erectile Brokenness and Untimely Discharge in men.
    • It is otherwise called 'Barrenness,' this brokenness makes it hard to get or keep an erection while having intercourse.
    • This medication likewise treats PE. In this situation, men discharge before they expect while participate in sexual activity.

    ReplyDelete
  16. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Cenforce 150 mg pills can also be used to treat high blood pressure, stroke, and heart disease. Cenforce is not for everyone. You should avoid it if you suffer from certain medical conditions such as low blood pressure or uncontrolled high pressure. This medication should not be taken with drugs like nitrates, which increase the level of nitrous dioxide in your bloodstream.

    The Vidalista 80 Mg tablets are compelling nonexclusive prescriptions that can deal with issues like erectile brokenness and acquainted side effects in men. This conventional Cialis medicine contains a functioning fixing known as Tadalafil that is remembered for a class of medications called PDE-5 inhibitors.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Learn about the aesthetic technologies and technique behind mesotherapy in our Meso Face and Meso Body courses, featuring the ways you can professionally solve and exceed your customer’s expectations with a high degree of innovation.

    ReplyDelete