"The NHS will last as long as there are folk left with the faith to fight for it"
Aneurin Bevan

Tuesday, 14 September 2010

Look at how the decent majority killed the poll tax

Brendan Barber, the General Secretary of the TUC, said this in the Indy yesterday:
"As people begin to see the unfairness of the cuts, the more support our alternative will win. Already we are getting the first hints that ministers are beginning to worry how voters will respond. That is why I look back to the poll-tax campaign for inspiration. That was the last great U-turn carried out by a Conservative prime minister. It went because the decent majority stood up and said that it was fundamentally unfair. MPs returned to Westminster to tell whips and ministers that their normally placid and safe seats were in uproar. There may have been disorder in central London, but that was an unwelcome distraction. The poll tax was abolished because Middle Britain said no."
For the last couple of months when people have asked me how to fight the NHS plans my advice, timid as it may sound, has been "go and complain to your MP, your county councillor, your district councillor and your town or parish councillor; make them known that you will not vote for someone who supports these plans". The only way to make Cameron change his mind is if he thinks that he will lose councillors in their thousands and lose LibDem support in Parliament and lose the support of enough of his MPs to make his position untenable.

This is how we will fight this policy and we can succeed. And besides, I've tasted the boots of a police officer, in my youth, and it didn't achieve anything; and anyway, I am just too old to pick fights with people younger than me.

Interesting Comments

These are interesting comments from Health Investor:
"Not only does coalition health secretary Andrew Lansley face similar anti-privatisation heat from Liberal Democrat backbenchers [as Blair did from his backbenchers], but he’s also under fire from fellow Tories, peeved that the NHS has been sheltered from spending cuts. At the same time, he’s announced that the vast majority of NHS managers are going to be sacked, then subsequently slagged-off independent providers and consultants for being “wasteful”: these are exactly the same people that are supposed to help make the white paper a reality. It is going to require a Herculean act of political strength to push the white paper through and, right now, Lansley is as weak as a baby."

The cat's been let out of the bag

GP commissioning is just one part of the White Paper. Far more important is Lansley's plans to privatise NHS hospitals. The private sector are not happy about this because they are inefficient and bloated and cannot match the cost-effectiveness of NHS treatment. However they do see an opportunity.

Kingsley Manning, a partner in Tribal’s healthcare business says:
"The opportunities for the sector may come when NHS trusts who have been told they must become foundation trusts fail. Then there will be a chance for the private sector to step in."
The cat's been let out of the bag.

GPs show "fierce opposition" to commissioning

Pulse report that the RCGP performed the largest survey of GPs yet and found that there is "fierce opposition" to GP commissioning.

"It warned plans for GP consortia to replace PCTs risked destabilising the NHS, and could swamp practices with extra workload and take clinicians away from the front line, while opening the door to the private sector."

The RCGP says:
"GPs will be seen as the purse-holders: this could reduce public trust and decrease their ability to advocate for patients, and they will be blamed for failures and cuts in services"
If Lansley cannot get GPs on board, the plans in the White Paper cannot be implemented.

Monday, 13 September 2010

Details about GP Consortia and Junior Doctor Training

Sir David Nicholson has written to various important people in the NHS to tell them about Commissar Lansley's plans. The document is available from the Department of Health website. Here are some pertinent points.

It is our intention that GP consortia would be statutory public bodies. We have said that each consortium would appoint an Accountable Officer and a Chief Financial Officer who would have responsibilities and accountabilities as leaders of their NHS organisations. However, beyond this the governance arrangements would be a matter for the consortia themselves to determine.
GP practices already make a key contribution to the overall quality of patient care and to the effective use of NHS resources. We propose, subject to discussion with the BMA and the profession, that a proportion of GP practice income should be linked to the outcomes that they achieve collaboratively through commissioning consortia and the effectiveness with which they manage financial resources.
GP consortia would be NHS bodies and NHS employers. The intention is that they would be statutory bodies, with powers and functions set out through primary and secondary legislation. We propose, however, that they would have flexibility in relation to their internal governance arrangements, beyond essential requirements for example, in relation to areas such as financial probity and accountability, reporting and audit.
Monitor would also have concurrent powers with the Office of Fair Trading to enforce Competition Law within the health and social care sector. These would be statutory powers that could be enforced outside of Monitor's licensing regime and could, therefore, be applied throughout the sector, including in primary care, and to all types of provider.
This looks like GPs will be subject to Competition Law.

The White Paper makes it clear that it is time to give employers greater autonomy for planning and developing the workforce alongside greater professional ownership of the quality of education and training. ... It would be set within the context of delivering appropriate investment in workforce education and training, whilst ensuring better outcomes for patients and value for money. It would also need to ensure appropriate checks, balances and accountability. The arrangements for education commissioning and delivery would be transparent and more efficient.
This seems to indicate that training will be the responsibility of hospitals. The "investment" part is important because at the moment training (and the salaries of trainee doctors and nurses) are paid by the Department of Health. The "investment" may indicate that individual hospitals will be responsible for this training cost. Considering that it costs £350k (or about 60 hip operations) to train a junior doctor this is not an insignificant cost. If doctors are made to shoulder this cost it would completely rule out any student from a low income background becoming a hospital doctor.

Private Healthcare LOVES The Tories

They really do. Here is the HealthInvestor Barometer the survey of private health providers. Look at the results for these questions:

Q: Which political party will do most to speed the recovery of the UK independent healthcare market?
A: Conservative 58%; Labour 10%; LibDem 2%

Q: Will the new government support the recovery of the UK independent healthcare market?
A: 64% agree/strongly agree

Q: Which political party will do most to expand the role of the private sector in the NHS?
A: Conservative 58%; Labour 8%; LibDem 2%

Q: Will the new government accelerate the expansion of the role of the private sector in the NHS?
A: Yes 86%; No 2%

Q: Is there a level playing field for providers to compete for primary care [GPs] contracts in the NHS?
A: Yes 14%; No 66% (see my post earlier today)

Q: Is there currently a fair market for secondary care providers [hospitals] to compete for NHS patients?
A: Yes 18%; No 69%

Q: Will budgetary pressures in the NHS boost demand for private care provision over the next two years?
A:Yes 79%; No 12%

The last question I quote above is the most important, the private sector expect the government to squeeze the NHS deliberately to force people to buy private healthcare. They say in the report:
"And our experts are almost unanimous in predicting that the looming real terms cut in the NHS budget will boost demand for private care provision for the next two years."
The interesting point is that the private providers do not believe in the talk of a "ring fence" and expect huge cuts in NHS funding. I agree with them, the "ring fence" will not survive the auntumn spending review.

More optimistically (for me) is that 75% think that the recession in private healthcare is not yet over (Yay! Let's hope it never does recover!) and that 55% think that the recovery will be 2013 or later. While the document does appear to be a glowing endorsement of the Conservatives there is this interesting comment:

"there is rumoured to be plenty of opposition in the Conservative ranks to the reforms so the vote could be a major test for the coalition whips"
I have always felt that the best way to fight Lansley's plans is to target the crucial 50+ grey vote in Tory areas. When they realise that these plans will affect them they will complain to their MP and that will force Lansley to re-think.

GPs worry

It is very clear that the main aim of the NHS White Paper is to privatise hospitals, but what about GPs? Well they are mostly small businesses and although Lord Darzi's reforms tried to bring in the big multi-nationals into primary care in a kind of "Tesco kills the small grocer" style, the changes implemented incompetently. The GPs were spared once, but now there is a new attack: Lansley's White Paper.

The Royal College of GPs have noticed that the White Paper spells the start of the end of the small business model of GP practices. Prof Steve Field, the RCGP chairman, said there was

'clear evidence' that if consortia were not big enough, many would fail.' But he called for failing consortia to be offered support or merged with neighbouring groups, instead of allowing private firms to take over.


How long will it be before you'll see a Virgin GP clinic in your town? Remember, to be viable a consortium has to be large, a population of 100,000 is the minimum, the GPC is talking about much larger consortia. So if a large healthcare company like Virgin takes over a consortium they will effectively have the monopoly over primary care in your area. Although you will have the choice to register with a new GP, the size of the consortia will mean that your "choice" will be to use a GP practice many miles away - in the next town, or county.