"The NHS will last as long as there are folk left with the faith to fight for it"
Aneurin Bevan

Saturday, 18 September 2010

LibDem Emergency Motion on NHS

Here is the text of the emergency motion to be debated at the LibDem conference tomorrow.

Emergency Motion 4: NHS White Paper
10 conference representatives
Conference notes the recent government white paper Equity and excellence: Liberating the NHS.

Conference further notes that existing Liberal Democrat policy:
A. Proposes increased local accountability for the NHS through directly elected Local Health Boards.
B. Supports empowerment of patients and equity for patients, particularly those with mental health problems.
C. Acknowledges the risk of destabilisation of NHS services through the use of private sector providers and sets criteria to minimise this risk.

Conference believes that:
i) The NHS is best served by co-operation and collaboration between hospitals.
ii) The patients with some of the most difficult healthcare requirements, such as elderly patients with multiple medical conditions, are likely to benefit the least from a competitive market, and suffer most where there is lack of co-ordination between providers of services.
iii) GP-led commissioning consortia are unlikely to have sufficient expertise in negotiating contracts to eliminate the risk of exploitation by corporate suppliers, and will need to procure specialised and often more expensive commissioning support, creating significant potential for conflicts of interest.
iv) A more fragmented health service often leads to poor opportunities for clinical training.
v) The white paper proposals will tend to increase choice and service provision in affluent and densely populated areas, and by attracting more services to the centres of population will reduce or remove services in poorer and more sparsely populated areas.

In particular conference restates the principles that every provider should:
a) Meet all NHS standards for Quality, Information and Communication.
b) Demonstrate that it provides value for money and does not undermine the local health
economy.
c) Ensure that no NHS patient shall receive a diminished service as a result of the introduction of a new provider.

Conference therefore urges the Coalition Government to:
1. Legislate to ensure that no company or organisation that offers services in support of the
commissioning process should either provide healthcare services directly, or have commercial links to a company or organisation that provides healthcare services.
2. Include in their plans explicit powers for local authorities to intervene if local services are at risk.
3. Ensure that any contract with a provider that does not train clinical staff should include a levy to support training of clinical staff in NHS facilities.

Conference also calls on all Liberal Democrat-led local authorities to use the proposed strategic role given to them in the white paper to protect the sustainability of an integrated health service, and to improve cooperation and communication between providers.

Applicability: England.

This is an interesting motion, not the best (that would be to scrap the entire white paper) but it shows that some LibDems are not happy with the intention that hospitals should "compete for patients" (not co-operate and collaborate as mentioned in the motion). The motion also infers that the white paper will fragment the NHS (this is the result of making every hospital a social enterprise) and that this will be bad for patients. It also says that the likely effect of the white paper proposals will be to provide a worse service in less affluent and more sparsely populated areas. Further, in reference to Lansley's intention to close hospitals by not "bailing them out" the motion says that local authorities should have explicit powers to do this.

I doubt if the Lib Dems have enough backbone to challenge Lansley this way, but it will be nice if they do.

Friday, 17 September 2010

Evidence that Lansley is wrong

Here's academic evidence that Lansley is totally wrong in his plans to change how hospitals are paid. Lansley's idea is that when you create a quasi- free market people will use the hospitals that give the best service and so quality goes up. Even a five year old will tell him that this is nonsense because (d'oh!) people much prefer to use their local hospital and so want that hospital improved. (Tony Blair got this idea at the beginning of his rule, but lost his way when his rich friends told him it would be better to use their private companies instead.)

Here is a blog post from Bristol University's Centre for Market and Public Organisation. OK, so the title first put me off "Healthcare competition saves lives" but the evidence is very interesting.
  • It found that hospitals located in areas where patients have had more choice since the NHS reforms [the choice of any hospital in the NHS] had higher clinical quality – as measured by lower death rates following admissions – and shorter lengths of stay than hospitals located in less competitive areas.
  • the hospitals in competitive markets did this without increasing total operating costs or shedding staff
There is a caveat: "One reason that the policy may be having this impact is the fact that prices are externally fixed." This is important because the hospitals were nominally not competing on price. In actual fact they were because two hospitals in the same area would be paid exactly the same amount for each procedure. But crucially, the Payment by Results payment system said that if a hospital provided the service for less than the fixed payment they could keep the surplus to be re-invested in the hospital (conversely, if a service generated a deficit then the hospital would have to cover it with surpluses from other services). A hospital generating large surpluses could provide more services, so there is an incentive to become more efficient. However, the fixed payment (or National Tariff) is calculated from the average cost of the procedure and so over time (as more hospitals get more efficient) the average will go down.
  • Research for the UK showed that when competition was introduced in the early 1990s in a regime that allowed hospitals to negotiate prices as well as quality there was a fall in clinical quality in more competitive areas. Waiting lists, however, declined for these hospitals.
This is important because it says that if commissioners (the people who actually pay for NHS care) can negotiate on price then the quality will go down. This is exactly what Lansley is planning! He intends to replace Payment by Results (based on the average price) to a system where the price is "best practice " (ie the cheapest) and is the starting point for negotiation since commissioners will be able to negotiate down from this value. This is a return to the system in the early 90s and CMPO says: "Competition under fixed prices appears to have beneficial results whilst competition where hospitals bargain over price and quality do not". The conclusion is interesting:

If competition is to work, price regulation has to be retained.  A free-for-all in prices would mean a return to the “internal market” of the 1990s, a regime in which hospitals competed vigorously on waiting times and ignored aspects of quality that are more difficult to measure. In addition, the tendency of the UK government to merge failing hospitals needs to be looked at carefully. Mergers are popular with finance ministries in NHS type systems because they remove what is often seen as ‘excess capacity’. However, while there are gains from removing poor managers when a hospital fails, removing capacity by merger will limit the extent of competition and may stifle the impetus given by competitive forces to improve outcomes for patients.
Lansley does say that there will be a premium on the "best practice" price for quality. As the CMPO blog says "quality" is difficult to measure, so it is unlikely to affect hospital income.

30% cut in NHS administrators

Yup, that is Lansley's plan, the clueless idiot. Why do I say he's clueless? Well, there is always some administration needed (like ensuring patients' notes are in the right place, that diagnostic tests are done at the right time and the results are on the doctor's desk when the patient visits) so cutting administrators is just plain daft.

For example, I attended a meeting at my local hospital a couple of weeks ago and they presented the results of a study they were doing on "patient pathways". Basically they performed some case studies of several patients listing the time that was taken for various activities: consultant visits, treatments, nurse contacts, meals sleeping and just waiting for one of the other activities. The last activity: just waiting, took the majority of the time. length of stay in hospital is directly related to costs: each hospital bed is an expensive resource and a patient in a bed waiting for treatment/tests/consultation or discharge is preventing another patient using the bed. The presenter gave an example of a patient having a blood test and pointed out that if this happened after four then the results would not be available before the consultant went home, meaning that the patient would have to spend another night in the hospital.

All of this is project management: you need someone to make sure that tests are done promptly, and that the results are available at the right time. Yes, you may also persuade consultants to change their working patterns but this is a management issue.

So now we have Lansley dictating that management is going to be cut by 45% and administration by 30%. How the fuck does he think that can be done? A good manager saves money, s/he makes the system efficient, cutting management by some arbitrary figure is nonsense.

So I was rather interested to see that junior doctors spend more time on administration than on formal training. With the diktats from Lansley about cutting management and administrators, junior doctors will find that they will have far more non-clinical work to do. And, of course, that will increase the drop-out rates (one in four currently).

Have a read of this doctor's account of the administration that she was required to do, and I challenge you not to think "but surely there is an administrator who can do it for you?"

Rationing

One of the most unpopular parts of the White Paper is that it explicitly says that GPs will have to ration healthcare. An odious task. Well, since there are huge cuts (efficiency savings are cuts) to be made in the next 4 years, many PCTs are thinking ahead and cutting already. Pulse report that cuts are being made to:
  • treatments for back pain
  • refusing all requests for IVF
  • tonsillectomy
  • counselling
  • hip operations
If you are in pain because of a back problem or a hip problem would you like to know that you will not get the care you need because Cameron lied about not cutting the health service? It is happening now.

But PCOs [Primary Care Organisations] are not cutting for fun. Indeed Pulse this week reveals many are panicking that they are not cutting quickly enough, with mid-year projections suggesting they are heading to bust budgets or miss efficiency targets. The likely outcomes are grim. PCOs may cut faster and deeper, shrugging off concerns over access to treatments and perhaps ignoring the new requirement, at least in England, to consult with GPs. Or they may shirk the budgetary challenge, in the knowledge they won’t be around to carry the can. If that happens, GPs will face a mountain of debt when they take over commissioning – debt the GPC concedes is likely to become the profession’s problem.
...and remember the Daily Mail? They complain all the time about some expensive, ineffective treatment that according to their rather dim, uneducated "journalists" are miracle cures being denied to us by the nasty people at NICE. Well Pulse says that the treatments that NICE recommends will be too expensive for the meagre budget that Lansley is giving GPs:
But it will not only be debt that becomes GPs’ problem. So will the legal duty to provide NICE-approved treatments, with consortia risking being sued if they fall short. As NICE green-lights more and more treatments, without worrying about anything as inconvenient as a budget, so the pressures on GPs will increase.
Pulse say that NICE should not be recommending as many treatments as they do:
NICE, too, should reform, by making recommendations within a notional annual budget, so GPs are not left with all the tough financial calls. Otherwise, the cynics on GP commissioning could be proved right – that it is just a way to shift blame for rationing onto GPs’ shoulders.
Now before you scream "bring in the private providers!" have a look at another report from Pulse.


GPC chair Dr Laurence Buckman told Pulse: ‘PCTs that have contracts with private organisations to provide hip surgery have for a long time had very restrictive criteria given to them by the private providers. So much so that you’ve got to be an Olympic athlete to get your hip replaced in some places.'
The sarcasm at the end of that quote is essentially saying that the private contracts cherry-pick: they will only do the easy cases. The private sector is NOT the solution.
 referral.'Buckman continues:

‘There are several people who presently are offered treatment for various illnesses who may not be offered treatment in the new world. If there’s evidence to show that that’s actually better for them, that the treatment is worse for them, then that’s not bad care, that’s good care. But where restrictions are put in merely to save money, I don’t think any of us would accept that.’
 Rationing will come, and you will have Lansley and Cameron to thank for it.

GPs to have child protection responsibilities

Thought that was the responsibility of local authority social services? Well it will be the responsibility of GP consortia under Lansley's plans.
"It also reveals GP consortia will take on the responsibility for child safeguarding from PCTs, although it admits this is beyond the experience of most PBC groups.
'This will be an important new role for GP consortia and one which will go beyond the experience of most existing GP commissioning groups,' the DH report said."
Yet another case of GPs being told to do something that they do not have the skills to do.

NHS Maternity Services

The obvious place to co-ordinate maternity services is GPs. That's obvious, so obvious that you probably feel insulted that I even thought to mention it.

However, Commissar Lansley, showing that he is completely clueless about healthcare, decided that commissioning for maternity services should rest with the super quango, the NHS Commissioning Board. Bizarre!

Actually, it is "outrageous" as one exasperated GP exclaimed at a recent GP meeting (reported by Pulse). Perhaps the Prime Minister might have a re-think, considering his recent change of circumsstances, and clearly the Department of Health think it is bonkers:
"A DH representative said it would take on board all feedback from delegates, and hinted at a possible U-turn. ‘A lot of people struggle to see how this fits with the general philosophy,’ he admitted. "

Thursday, 16 September 2010

Conflict

An article on the HSJ website today is titled: "Conflicting messages from the top hint at growing resistance". It reports that Andrew Lansley and the top civil servant in the NHS, Sir David Nicholson, are providing conflicting messages about the planned changes. On the one hand Commissar Lansley is attacking just about every part of the NHS in his attempt to break it apart into private corporations. On the other hand, Sir David recognises that if any change has to be made it has to be done by the people who work for the NHS and hence he is carefully asking for help. The HSJ article gives the 18 week target as an example:
Mr Lansley trumpeted the end of the 18 week waiting target, Sir David chooses to specifically remind NHS chief executives that it “remains a constitutional right” and commissioners have “a responsibility to ensure that commitment is met”.
This is a clear conflict, especially since Lansley made targets a political issue (even thought he is totally wrong about targets, because patients really do like them since they guarantees them prompt care).

As a civil servant Sir David has to do what his political master tells him to do, but as we well know from Yes, Minister, the Sir Humphrey's of Whitehall usually know best and implement what they know to be best.