"The NHS will last as long as there are folk left with the faith to fight for it"
Aneurin Bevan

Thursday, 23 September 2010

Lansley Bails Out Hospital

To most of us a bail-out is free money. It is not. It never is because there are always strings attached. The banks (RBS, HBOS, Northern Rock) were "bailed out" by the government buying preferential shares in the companies, the banks got the money which they could use to pay off their debts, but the government has the shares which means that in the future they can sell the shares and re-coup their cost.

The NHS white paper says (1.22):
"We are very clear that there will be no bail-outs for organisations which overspend public budgets."
This says that the government will not give free money to hospitals who go into debt. It also means that the government will not give loans to hospitals that go into debt (remember: bail-outs, like the banks, can be loans too). The government's plan is that if a hospital goes into debt it should take out a commercial loan, presumably secured on the hospital's assets. Unless, that is, you are a hospital in Tory Berkshire, in which case Lansley will bail you out. Heatherwood and Wexham Park Hospitals in Wrexham, Berkshire is in debt, and so today Lansley announced that he will lend the trust
"to enable them to turn around their financial position while maintaining a high standard of patient care."
Just in case you thought that this was a bail out (like the banks were bailed out) he added:
"I have been clear that this is not a bail out - it will need to be repaid in full and is conditional on the Trust demonstrating that they will meet their ongoing commitments in terms of quality and financial stability."
So there you have it, yet more doublespeak from Commissar Lansley, just because he says that it is not a bail out (which it is) then that means it is not a bail out (but it is).

Actually, I am rather happy that Lansley has done this, because the next time a hospital needs a bail out and he tries to refuse we can always point him to the Heatherwood and Wexham Park Hospitals precedent.

UPDATE:

Roy Lilley adds the details. His entire post is worth a read, but start at the second piece "Trust gets massive bail-out". Lilley points out that out of a budget of £214m it needs to save £46m. Why is this the case? Lilley says: "The problem is simple to diagnose; there is just not enough money in the local health economy". The issue is that there are other hospitals in the region (too many?) and that there is not enough money to go around. No-one likes their local hospital closing, and a responsible Health secretary would get together all the stakeholders in the area to come up with a credible plan. Then start a wide public consultation to get the public's point of view and respond to it. Instead we have a Health secretary obsessed with the market. The bail-out is £18m over ten years and Lilley comments:
"Lansley is oiling a slippery slope with money he doesn't have.  The sad story of this hospital is not untypical.  There will be many more like it and they won't all have an ex-employee who is an MP, with mates in government, to help bail them out."
Last night (23 Sept) I attended a public meeting where several GPs said that the white paper was designed to fail. That is, NHS hospitals will be starved of staff and when they fail - as they inevitably will - the Health Secretary will say that the NHS is not fit for purpose and will invite in the private sector.

Increasing the Postcode Lottery

NICE is evidenced-based. They evaluate treatments and determine if they are effective clinically and cost effective. There is some controversy over their role, but since there will always be a shortage of money there will always be rationing of some kind. NICE aims to make sure that the rationing is equitable and evidence-based. A totally free-market system is likely to end up in the drug companies charging what the patient will pay, rather than the cost, or value of the treatment. Whatever the Daily Mail say about NICE, we should all be thankful that NICE are calm, sensible and base their decisions on facts.

So we have this bizarre new policy from Commissar Lansley to change to "value-based pricing". I have already said that this is a nonsense policy, and I have pointed out that their example of Lucentis is nonsense since the drug was priced specifically at "what the patient would pay to keep their sight" rather than the actual cost of the treatment.

Now we see that the government is changing the role of NICE (Healthcare Republic). A Department of Health spokeswoman said:
"[NICE's] role will increasingly focus on how to deliver authoritative advice to clinicians on the most effective treatments and on development of quality standards, not acting as an arbiter on the availability of drugs."
This is a serious change. David Willetts says "NICE will continue to offer advice but we will ensure more decisions are taken at GP level". The problem is when there is a ptient sitting in the surgery, will a GP say "there is a drug that you can take, but it is expensive and will only give you a few extra weeks, and may even shorten your life"? This is, in effect, what NICE were saying when they declined to recommend Avastin. It is far better for this decision to be made by a separate, evidence based body.

And then there is another problem. Since NICE is a national body (that is the N in NICE) their decisions affect everyone. The problem with forcing GPs to make the decision is that different GPs will make different decisions based on the same evidence. GPC deputy chairman Dr Richard Vautrey says:

"When it comes to high cost drugs, whether it be NICE or consortia making decisions, the reality is the money is simply not available for everyone to have everything that they want. Patient care will not be improved and the changes risk widening postcode prescribing. It is also likely to be a recipe for chaos if this is implemented at the same time as scrapping practice boundaries. The danger is that patients simply register elsewhere in the country just to get a particular drug and this will cause great problems to those practices who try to offer good quality care to remote patients."
Bizarrely Willetts says that this could result in GPs prescribing quack remedies like homeopathy (Pulse):
"They will have the ability to prescribe things like homeopathy even if they do not meet any NICE requirements. If GPs do detect very strong patient demand, they will be able to respond to that. Under our new role, there will be greater scope for GPs to respond to patient demand."
Any system which allows a patient to demand distilled water treatment from their GP is certainly going backwards. Willetts is supposed to be the Science Minister, so why is he promoting a system that will allow the NHS to pay for quack remedies? That is not science.

Wednesday, 22 September 2010

Awards

Everyone likes to be appreciated, I certainly do.

Many years ago a magazine told me that one of my books had been nominated by their readers as the best book published that year so I was invited to the "awards ceremony" (OK dinner at a restaurant in London). Of course I was excited. However, when it came to the "ceremony" it turned out that I came second to a book which I had been given by the publisher (ie I didn't even pay for it) and I felt was poorly written and technically incorrect in many places. My books are neither, so how did I come second?

Well, it was the methodology of the voting. The magazine had asked its readers to email-in the titles of their favourite books. This was not a survey, carefully balancing the respondents to make sure that they are representative of the "community" (like opinion polls). And neither was it an expert and informed panel (like the Man-Booker prize). No, the people who voted were those that like voting: a self-selected electorate. I was happy with the result, because it gave me a free dinner in a swanky London restaurant, but I did not tell anyone that I had come second to an inferior book.

After the awards were handed out I congratulated the winner and we chatted for a while (well, the drinks were free) and I asked him what the sales of his book were like. It turned out that his inferior book had sold third of the sales of my book. (That book of mine has sold 40,000 world wide, which is not bad for a $50 technology book.)


So why do I mention this? Well I find that I am now number 85 in the Total Politics list of the most popular Labour blogs, and because of this I am entitled to use the image above. The problem is that this is just as worthless as coming second in the best book of the year list. The methodology of the Total Politics list is ropey at best: you email TP your top five list of blogs and they then generate the list according to the categorisation of your blog as registered on their site. Yet again, the people voting are self-selected; there is no effort to make the "electorate" representative of the population of the UK, or of internet users, or of political blog readers.

It turns out that I was right to list my blog as "Labour" rather than "left-wing". There are far more "left-wing" blogs than Labour (even though some on the "left-wing" list, like Red Rag, are clearly Labour blogs), so it is easier to get on the Labour list than the "left-wing" list. For example, if you compare the top 100 left wing blogs with the top 100 Labour blogs you'll see that Stilettoed Socialist, Ellie Gellard's site, is listed as number 100 in the left-wing blog list but number 42 in the Labour blog list. Assuming that the same number of votes puts Ellie's site at those two positions (which is a reasonable assumption), this indicates that you have to get more votes to get a placing in the left-wing blog list than the Labour list. My site is 40 places below Ellie's site on the Labour list, which shows why my site is not in the left-wing list. Indeed, all of the top 42 Labour sites are in the top 100 left-wing list and so the Labour list is a subset of the left-wing list (as you would expect). Clearly being partisan is a good thing!

So drawing a parallel to the anecdote I gave above, I had a look at the traffic to my blog. No I won't tell you the figures because I don't want the people reading this to feel too exclusive! But I certainly cannot feel superior like I was knowing that my book sales were better than the book judged "better" than mine.

So I have put the Total Politics "award" gif on my site's sidebar knowing that actually it came from just a handful of votes. I suppose it is like being a LibDem minister: you have to achieve far less to be appreciated far more!

Tuesday, 21 September 2010

GPs are Revolting!

Pulse report that "the BMA is riven with divisions over how to respond to the white paper" and there they have been unable to come to a consensus. Further, Pulse says:

The GPC will say it backs plans to put GPs in the driving seat on commissioning but will demand answers to a set of outstanding concerns, including:
  • lack of detail about managerial support for GP consortia
  • GP consortia being saddled with debts from failing PCTs
  • GPs being locked into long-term deals with private firms, including PFI agreements.
Further Pulse reports that Dr Jane Lothian, secretary of Northumberland LMC, said GPs were torn.

'In terms of concept, we are extremely positive. The thing we are concerned about is the destruction of SHAs and PCTs. As much as we love to spar with them, everybody has work-ed very hard to get the system working. We’re very concerned organisational memory will go.'

Bad strategy is that which you cannot afford

On the PM programme yesterday, BBC Radio 4, Eddie Mair interviewed Colonel Richard Williams who commanded the SAS in Afghanistan. It is worth a listen all 8 minutes of it starting at 22:20 (iPlayer). Colonel Williams is very calm and precise, and as a commander of the SAS he was clearly very experienced about the deployment in Afghanistan.

The main message of the interview was that the problems the army suffered in Afghanistan between 2001 to 2007 were because of poor military design and not from a lack of resources. He said that it was: "not a political issue, that is a military issue".

Mair asked Williams about the result of "the poor judgement" and Williams said there were two: the loss of life and the loss of Britain's reputation as the "primary, most effective, world-class counter insurgency force". Williams added that "Since 2007 I think a lot of work has happened to recover that reputation, but there are still deficiencies".

These are serious admissions, but who is to blame for the problems? Colonel Williams said that "there were a series of arguments which were presented to the commanders on the ground which forced them (in their own words) to the nine outposts of which Sangin was one" and that with six helicopters they "could only really support perhaps three operating bases". The "arguments" were being presented from the high command in the military and imposed on the commanders on the ground, imposed on the people who knew that they only had the resources to operate three bases.

When Mair asked who was responsible for those poor decisions between 2001 and 2007, Colonel Williams said "They rest with the military. In all of the discussions that I was privy to, but not necessarily part of, the military requested a series of resources relative to the tasks outlined. They were given those resources and in both cases be it Souther Iraq or Afghanistan they didn't deploy those resources as effectively as they should do."

Mair reiterated: "you're saying, in essence, that they [the military] did have what they wanted but they made a mess of deploying it?" Colonel Williams agreed. He said "it is slightly unfair of the military to blame the politicians for a lack of resources when actually it was a bad military design." He said that one of his favourite guidelines was "Bad strategy is that which you cannot afford" and explained, "if you have only six helicopters then [you] design an operation that six helicopters can support." He went on to explain that the military in Afghanistan designed operations that they did not have the resources to implement and that when he was asked for his opinion about the challenges in Helmand, he specifically told his superiors the dangers of over stretching the deployment, but his warnings were ignored.

This backs up Brown's constant assertion that he met all requests for resources, which the Conservatives constantly attacked. But rather interestingly, he puts the blame for the problems squarely on the military leadership.

Monday, 20 September 2010

Social Enterprises

Ask anyone what is the greatest British institution and they will answer: the NHS.

Ask them to tell you what they they think embodies our NHS and they will say: our NHS hospitals.

Yet in 2014 those three letters N-H-S will be removed from the signs of every hospital in England, for good reason: they will no longer be part of the NHS.

The reason is section 4.21 of the NHS White Paper: 
"Our ambition is to create the largest and most vibrant social enterprise sector in the world. ... As all NHS trusts become foundation trusts, staff will have an opportunity to transform their organisations into employee-led social enterprises that they themselves control."
Rather than there being one organisation, the NHS, owning all hospitals, the White Paper policies will fragment the system into 250 separate, independent organisations. A social enterprise is not publicly owned, it is not publicly run. They are private companies with a "social purpose" and this typically means that they are not-for-profit. In fact the government says that they will be "employee-led" which effectively means management buyouts. Currently NHS management remuneration is approximately a third that of the private sector (NHS Confederation), so you can imagine that one of the first things that the board of a (former NHS) social enterprise hospital will do is give the board a huge pay rise and there will be nothing that you can do. If you complain about an NHS hospital to your local councillor ot MP they will be able to lobby the hospital management and make sure that changes are made: this is the advantage of public ownership. But if you complain to your councillor or MP about a (former NHS) social enterprise hospital they will shrug their shoulders and say "it is nothing to do with me". and of course it will not be, your complaint would be the same as making a complaint about someone being rude to you at Sainsburys or Tescos.

But the government, when it says "the largest social enterprise sector in the world" are admitting that this has not been carried out anywhere else in the world. They are admitting that it is an experiment: they are experimenting with our very lives!

A social enterprise hospital is not part of the NHS. This will have profound effects on staff in terms of pay and conditions, pensions, job mobility and training.

The Transfer of Undertakings (Protection of Employment) regulations - TUPE - will apply when a hospital becomes a social enterprise. This will transfer NHS employment T&C to the new business, including the right to continue to contribute to the NHS pension. But the regulations apply only to that one transfer. So if an employee moves to another hospital (as is common currently in the NHS) the employee will be moving from one business to another and treated as a new employee in the new business. This means that they will be employed under new conditions and will no longer be able to contribute to the NHS pension.Ultimately NHS T&C and the NHS pension will be phased out.

This is likely to have an important effect on job mobility since employees not wanting to lose the right to continue contributing to the NHS pension will be reluctant to change jobs. When it comes to pay bargaining, there will be no national pay rates. This will mean different hospitals will pay different rates and the result will inevitably mean that pay will not match inflation. And it will mean that the big teaching hospitals will be able to pay higher rates and attract the more able staff, whereas district general hospitals will pay far less and be unable to attract the best staff and the quality of treatments will suffer.

Currently NHS training is funded by central government (Multi-Profession Education and Training levy - MPET). This is around £6bn annually paid by the Department of Health to Strategic Health Authorities which pay for the training of doctors, nurses, scientific and admin staff. However, this payment from central government not only covers the training costs, but also the salary of the employee while training. For example, as a doctor learns more then progressively more of their salary is paid by the hospital. In two years of foundation training the Department of health will pay first 100% and then 50% of the doctor's salary, in the four years of specialty training the Department of Health will pay between 50% and 100% of the doctor's pay. The same is true for trainee nurses staff.

A social enterprise hospital is an independent business, the government will have no responsibility for the training of their staff (why should it? is the government responsible for the training of BAe's staff or GlaxoSmithKline's staff?). The White Paper is coy about this £6bn of training it simply says (4.33): 
"Healthcare employers and their staff will agree plans and funding for workforce development and training; their decisions will determine education commissioning plans."
Note that there is nothing in the White Paper that says that there will be continued funding MPET, it does say: 
"All providers of healthcare services will pay to meet the costs of education and training. Transparent funding flows for education and training will support the level playing field between providers."
It is estimated that it costs £350K to train a junior doctor. If there is no guaranteed funding from central government then this cost will be a huge burden on hospitals (£350k is about 60 hip replacements). If this cost is put on student doctors then it will dissuade students from lower income families to train to become a hospital doctor. Currently the BMA say that a medical student graduates with a debt of £37k (or £45k for a London university); that debt is a powerful force against lower-income students going to medical school, and consequently medicine is a predominately middle class profession. But imagine the effect of the student having to take out an additional loan of £350k to train as a hospital doctor. This will dissuade even middle class students, and we will return back to the days of Sir Lancelot Spratt where only the very richest could even think of becoming a hospital doctor. (And since the very richest do not have a monopoly on brains and ability, hospitals will inevitably be staffed by less able doctors.)

Social enterprises will have profound effects on patients too. At the moment you are treated within the NHS, so if you need more specialist care from another hospital you simply move to another part of the same organisation. When hospitals become social enterprises (and in Oliver Letwin's words "compete for patients") you will be regarded as a source of income, rather than a patient. So will a hospital be willing to lose a source of income to another competitor? No. Currently we give doctors our trust that their decisions will be made on a purely clinical basis. But in the future, every clinical decision will have a financial effect on the hospital: your doctor may be making a financial decision and not a clinical decision.

When a hospital becomes a social enterprise it will no longer be financially secure. The reason is that currently risk pooling is provided by the government. The government effectively says that there will be NHS hospital services in your area and if your local hospital goes into debt the government is there to provide interim financial support while the hospital is reconfigured. The Conservative government is removing this guarantee (the only service they will guarantee is A&E), they say that the market will make the provision, so if your local hospital does not have sufficient funding and it goes into debt, then the market is saying that a hospital is no needed in your area and so the hospital will close. The government are explicit about this in the White Paper section 1.22:
"We are very clear that there will be no bail-outs for organisations which overspend public budgets."
This is a sink or swim policy.

Hospitals also get risk pooling insurance through the NHS to pay for medical negligence and also for a wide range of non-clinical liabilities including personal injury sustained by visitors to NHS premises, to claims arising from breaches of the Human Rights Act, the Data Protection Act and the Defective Premises Act and also cover for defamation, professional negligence by employees and liabilities of directors. As a social enterprise a hospital will have to cover all of these itself through commercial insurance policies and an inevitable rise in costs.

The fact that the government no longer wants to provide risk pooling for the NHS shows that it is shirking its responsibility to its citizens.

So will these hospitals have a secure future? No. The so-called "ring fence" is a fiction, it was simply a ploy to deceive the electorate into believing that the NHS was safe in Cameron's hands: it is not.  The Kings Fund say that to be funded enough to provide the current service the NHS needs a year-on-year increase of 4% to 6% which is far more than the RPI increase that Lansley is promising.

The NHS has to make £20bn of efficiency savings by 2014. What this means is that there will be £20bn less money over those four years than is needed to provide the service. It is most definitely a cut, it may be smaller than the 25% cut that other public services are suffering, but when you consider that inflation in healthcare is twice CPI and that demands on the NHS increase every year as the population ages, just standing still with an annual inflation increase is difficult enough. To make £20bn of "efficiency savings" is nigh-on impossible.

This is in the face of a further cut in hospital funding when the government cuts the money paid to every hospital for each procedure (treatment, clinic appointment, operation), so that they are paid only the "best practice" or lowest rate. (Remember when we last had a "pay the lowest rate" policy? It was in the Thatcher years when they introduced "competitive tendering" in cleaning which resulted in filthy, unhygienic hospitals. Well Lansley wants that policy to be applied to clinical procedures too.)

Each hospital will be a separate business, and they will be expected to "compete for patients". This is not the spirit of co-operation and collaboration that we are used to in the NHS. But the government is serious about this. They even want to make hospitals subject to Competition Law (and why not? they will be real, private businesses). White Paper section 4.27 says:
"Monitor will have concurrent powers with the Office of Fair Trading to apply competition law to prevent anti-competitive behaviour"
This means that any other business (social enterprise, or private business) will be able to launch a legal case against your local hospital for being a monopoly provider. This is not an idle threat. In most cities you could argue that there is competition because the concentration of several hospitals merely means that you as a patient have a small extra distance to travel to use a competitor. But in rural areas this is not the case. There is typically just one hospital trust covering a large area and by necessity it is a monopoly. Your local hospital could provide an excellent service, but will still be subject to cases brought under competition laws. And once hospitals are subject to UK competition laws, they will be subject to EU competition laws, which means that cases can be brought against your local hospital being a monopoly supplier by an EU healthcare company.

The White Paper also says (4.28)
"[Monitor will] require monopoly providers to grant access to their facilities to third parties"
This means that private providers (or even other former NHS hospitals, now social enterprises) will be allowed access to your local hospital's facilities. As you walk the corridors of your local hospital you will see the uniforms of doctors and nurses of your hospital, as well as Serco, HCA, Spire, GHG and many others. You will also see private patients using the facilities in your local hospital, and inevitably they will go straight to the front of any queue. Even if your local hospital refuses to treat private patients (as my local hospital does and has pledge to continue to do) they will not have the choice because Monitor will force them to allow private providers to use their facilities.

Kingsley Manning, a partner in Tribal’s healthcare business says: 
"The opportunities for the sector may come when NHS trusts who have been told they must become foundation trusts fail. Then there will be a chance for the private sector to step in."
The private sector are simply waiting for (former NHS) hospitals to go into debt so that they can take them over. This is, of course, the whole purpose of the White paper.

All of this is concerning. The government intends for all hospitals to be taken out of public ownership, subject to vicious cuts in funding and left open to the predatory actions of the private sector. Thankfully, UNISON is spearheading a campaign against social enterprises. Currently it is community health services that are under threat, but in the future it will be every hospital. If you value the NHS then you should fight to keep your NHS hospital public.

Do LibDem hearts still beat on the left?

This is the title of a post over at Next Left. Here Sunder Katwala provides a write up of a fringe meeting at the LidDem conference. One comment from Norman Lamb piqued me.

Remember that when the whole "Death Tax" argument flared up, it was Lamb who was most effective in pointing out that the Conservatives were talking nonsense. Lansley had called Burnham's social care plans a "Death Tax" and gave as an alternative an unworkable, underfunded, optional scheme. Burnham went to pieces showing that he was completely unable to attack an unworkable policy when it was presented by a bully like Lansley. Lamb, however, was calm and thoughtful and pointed out with great effect that Lansley's plans could not work. Lambs attacked panicked Lansley into providing more policy details on the hoof and consequently killed Lansley's argument.

Here is the quote from Lamb:

"It is a Coalition of independent parties. It is not a pact."
But this is not what has happened. The LibDems have been subsumed in government. Even their greatest "achievement", the raising of the income tax allowance, was not a unique LibDem policy. David Cameron said before the election that he wanted to do this, but it was too expensive and so was not a priority for him. In other words, the policy that was implemented was not a LibDem policy, it was a Tory policy.

Then we have that worthless rag the "Coalition Agreement", the Conservative government are simply not following it, and the LibDems are unable to do anything about it. (Like everything in this government there is no accountability.) In the CA there is a LibDem policy that PCTs (Primary Care Trusts, the organisation that allocates NHS funding locally) should be replaced with elected Health Boards. However, the Conservative government are not doing this, instead, they are replacing PCTs with semi-autonomous, self appointed GP Commissioning Boards. In other words, the very worst of the PCTs (that they are appointed and face-less) are being spun as the strengths of the new system. So what happened to the LibDem "moderating influence"? Lansley (who Lamb locked horns with effectively at the election) simply said "we had a look at elected Health Boards and decided that they would not work" and instead went back to his original idea, another policy that has not been tested and (according to most GPs) will not work.

The coalition is still in its honeymoon. In a years time LidDems will be weeping about what little influence they have had. If Lamb, or more significantly, Clegg, was true to his word he would stick rigidly to the Coalition Agreement and not allow a millimetre of deviation (I think someone else said something similar recently), because once the CA is seen as being optional the Tories will simply make no attempt to follow it, nor try to accommodate Libdem policies.