One of the best features of the NHS is that you know that whatever unforeseen healthcare issue you have, you will always get treatment according to clinical need. Anyone who waters down this basic principle of the NHS does not deserve to hold public office.
Enter the concept of personal budgets for healthcare. I will write more about this subject but here are some initial thoughts. The first point to make is that all the major political parties are in favour of personal budgets. This would imply that the majority of people are in favour of them, and that there is a universal demand for them. But stop anyone in the street and ask them about NHS personal budget and you'll find that they either have not heard about them, or they are against them. If you get a positive response for personal budget, it will be usually followed up with the hope that it will result in more money spent on them. The sad truth is that there is no more money, and that in the future the money spent on healthcare will decrease, not increase.
What are personal budgets? The idea is that through a personal budget patients will be offered more choice and control over their care. However, at the moment the policy makers are very careful to say that they will be offered only be patients with long term conditions. Policy makers are also careful to say that they will be only offered to patients with "stable and predictable conditions". The combination of these two restrict their application to a limited number of perfect patients. Finally, policy makers are extremely careful to say that no one will ever be denied treatment as a result of having a personal budget. Life is never perfect, but let us assume the best case for patients.
If no one will be denied care, this implies that the situation we have at the moment - where care is according to need - will be the baseline, that is, the minimum spend. Politicians are acutely aware that they must not be seen to be introducing rationing. It would be political suicide for a politician to be seen to be introducing any policy that require patients to pay for top-up for NHS care. This means that when personal budgets are introduced they must be more than what the patient would otherwise receive through their existing NHS care.
Patients will not be simply handed a pot of cash to spend however they like. Instead, they will be handed a limited list of approved treatments (or providers) or patients will be asked to have a treatment or provider approved before they will be able to spend the money from their budget. This requires the work of an administrator, advisor or advocate and it will be in addition to anny administrators currently used. Further, since this will be devolved down to the patient level, rather than across a large number of patients, it will not benefit from economies of scale. The administrative costs of personal budgets will be more than not having personal budgets.
To make the budget more personal, a patient must be given access to the budget. Whatever access the patient is given, it is unlikely to be actual cash, otherwise the patient would be able to spend the budget on something other than healthcare (for example, heating bills). Instead, the personal budget is likely to be in some other form of currency: for example vouchers. The conversion of these other currencies will have a cost.
When you add all of this together, personal budgets will cost more for the same treatment than not having personal budgets. The only way that personal budgets can be made popular for those that will receive them, is if they will result in more spent on those patients. However, there is a fixed overall healthcare budget so if more money is spent on patients with personal healthcare budgets, this means spending less on those without them. I object to any policy that results in taking money from one patient to give to another if there is no clinical benefit for both patients.
Further, I dislike quoting Liam Bryne but "I'm afraid to tell you there's no money left" is apposite. Any policy, in the foreseeable future, that involves spending more will be rejected by the Treasury, so therefore every government policy must result in spending less. Since personal budgets involve spending more on administration, they mean spending less on healthcare, and any temporary rise in spending on healthcare designed to make personal budgets popular will ultimately result in bigger cuts in the future.
I can never support personal budgets.
Friday, 2 September 2011
Thursday, 1 September 2011
Trivial
I was first diagnosed with diabetes in 1976, in those days it was called juvenile diabetes or sometimes insulin-dependent diabetes, now it is called type 1 diabetes (because these days type 2 can occur in children, and insulin is sometimes used to treat type 2 diabetes). My diabetes was monitored by a six monthly appointment with a consultant paediatrician at the local hospital. My memories are of gleaming polished floors and patrician (and all male) consultants. The hospital was build before WWII with 70's extensions, and the paediatrics department was in the old part. Perhaps it was my age, but the enduring impression is of doctors whose opinions you could not question, not quite the consultant barking orders at you (like Sir Lancelot Spratt) but certainly everything he said was followed to the letter.
Appointments took a couple of hours because other than the consultation with the paediatrician there was also a trip to the pathology department to have several tubes of blood taken which were then tested for the following appointment (later on, finger prick tests - or more accurately finger jabs because they cut a wide hole in my finger - were introduced so I would have one of those as well as having blood removed from my arm). After leaving the hospital there was always a trip to the cake shop to make up for the blood tests (remember, this was the 70s). Although I do remember it taking time to go between various appointments in the hospital (as well as the blood tests) I do not remember waiting long to be seen.
When I reached 16, I was moved to the adult diabetic clinic in the same hospital where I was seen by a diabetes consultant. The adult clinic that was held in outpatients which was in one of the 70s buildings. To a 16 year old the adult diabetes clinic was a shock. My impression was that diabetes was a condition of the elderly and I was somewhat weird that I had an old people's disease. There must have been teenagers (or even middle aged people) who attended that clinic, but I never saw them, it was the old people I saw.
One distinct memory is queuing up for disposable needles at the hospital pharmacy. I had a glass syringe and so-called reusable needles. However, these blunted quickly which caused scaring and fat to disappear from my injection sites (30 years on, I still have lumps in my thighs from using reusable needles). Part of the problem was the impure insulin. When I was first diagnosed I took bovine insulin and after a few years I moved to porcine insulin; the hospital also started prescribing disposable needles. My control was much better on the porcine insulin, but since this was around the time I started using disposable needles I don't know if the improvement was due to the needles or the insulin. However, one thing is for sure, disposable needles made injecting quite a lot less unpleasant. I could not get disposable needles from my community pharmacy because GPs were not allowed to prescribe them (I was told: because of the cost), so I had to wait for a hospital appointment to get them.
My memories of the hospital adult clinic was not of gleaming floors, instead it was of long waits in waiting rooms full of old, ill people. I distinctly remember peeling paint everywhere.
During this time I had the same GP. She had a very much "hands off" attitude and since (other than the diabetes) I was healthy I never saw her. She did, however, make one of the best recommendations I received soon after I was diagnosed: she gave my mother the address of another family with a child my age who had diabetes. We learned a lot more about living with diabetes from that family than we did from any of the clinicians we talked to. Since diabetes is 24x7 and you can never "cure" it, learning to live with the condition is vital.
When I went to university (and later, when I got a job in the city where I had studied), I went to the hospital diabetic clinic (conveniently at the university hospital). The clinic was only for people of my age: young adults, and discovered that I was not the only young person with the condition. The university hospital was newly built and modern. There was none of that light blue paint that seemed to be used everywhere in the hospital I attended when younger. Instead, there was light wood everywhere and they even had carpeted floors in the clinic. My appointments were always on time, this (and the location - I could get to the diabetic clinic from the university department where I studied via a short cut through the medical school) meant that I could attend the clinic without missing much lecture time. I do remember being seen more often than not by registrars - perhaps an attribute of a teaching hospital - who were mostly female and not much older than me. (Yes, I was a young man, I paid close attention to such things.) After graduating I got a job at the university, so again, it was convenient to take little more than an hour off to attend a clinic.
My treatment changed over this period. When I started at university I used disposable syringes (the needles were attached) and porcine insulin. After a couple of years I moved to human insulin and then after I graduated I changed to using a pen. The first insulin pens would deliver two units of insulin per click, since I had a big dose (around 20) it would mean clicking the pen multiple times making sure I remembered how many. On one occasion I went out to dinner with some work friends and just before the food appeared I went into the toilets to inject. I remember hearing the characteristic click-click-click of an insulin pen from the stall next door and was surprised to discover that it was the technician who worked for me in my lab. I had known him for two years and I didn't know he was diabetic, nor he know that I was.
Again, my GP had a "hands off" approach: the treatment of diabetes was the consultant's responsibility, although I did find that when I occasionally went to my GP he would point out that there was a connection between the condition I presented and my diabetes (usually the fact that my blood sugar was too high). My only contact was the regular request for prescriptions.
A decade later, married with a child, I moved house to follow my job. I registered with the local GP and at my first appointment I asked to be referred to the local hospital. "We don't refer patients to the hospital clinic: we have our own diabetic clinic". I had registered at a fundholding practice although I did not know what this meant. At the first diabetic clinic the doctor told me that he had just been on a course about diabetes. Was this supposed to reassure me by telling me how up-to-date his knowledge was? I don't know, but his next statement dismissed that reassurance: "... but since you've had diabetes for 17 years I think you know more about diabetes than me!" Oh dear.
The practice was a new build and close to my home. However, I worked half an hour's drive away (coincidentally, where I worked was a ten minute walk to the local hospital). Since diabetic clinics were during my working hours it meant that if I had a diabetic clinic I would have to take the morning off work. From memory, appointments were prompt, possibly because it was a new venture for the practice and they had given it more than enough resources. Since I did not see the doctor other than for my diabetes (at this point my control was much better due to the modern insulin I was taking) I do not know how long a patient would wait for a GP appointment.
To be fair to the doctor in the GP clinic, he did notice when there were changes in my eyes and he immediately referred me to the local hospital for laser treatment. This was like going back in time: the hospital was pre-war and some of it was Victorian. My memories are of long waits sitting on plastic chairs in corridors. The eye clinic did emergency work so often I would see someone lead in (or pushed in on a wheelchair) with bandaged eyes and then told my appointment would be delayed as they treated the emergency case. The clinic was just ten minutes walk from where I worked, but the long periods of time I spent waiting for appointments meant I would have to take an afternoon off work. Treatment during week days have a knock-on effect. I taught week long courses and it was not convenient for me to take a morning off halfway through the course, but if I was given an appointment for treatment I had no option, I had to attend on that particular day for fear of not being able to get an alternative date.
Then I changed jobs and moved house (now with another child). The town had two GP practices with surgeries 100m of each other. Both were modern buildings and since there was not much difference between them, we chose more or less at random. At my first GP clinic I told the GP that I wanted to be referred: this time I decided that I was not going to accept just the GP clinic. The GP said "that's fine, we will put you down as shared care".
So now I was seen by the local hospital clinic and the GP clinic. The contrast was marked. The hospital was largely pre-war and the outpatients was in a large 80s extension that had not been completed. The clinics were crowded, (mostly elderly people) and I never had an appointment on time. In those early days at some point during the afternoon a nurse would announce that the doctor had been called away to attend an emergency and so our appointments were delayed (a diabetic clinic for me was always a case of turn up at 2 and be seen after 5).
Although the outpatients department was new it was still tatty: I guess it had not been repainted since I had been built. The older parts of the hospital were worse. The hospital was made up of several building of various ages and there was a long corridor (a covered walkway) between them. For years it seemed that the hospital had no money to replace broken ceiling panels, so occasionally when walking along that corridor you could see the pipes and wires that were the very guts of the hospital. The eye clinic I attended was in the old part and it was cramped with patients waiting on chairs along a narrow corridor. There was one positive memory: whenever I attended the diabetic or eye clinic I had to take my diary because after my appointment I could make the next appointment and was given a specific time and date. This meant that there was even a possibility of ensuring that the appointment would not be when I was away on holiday, although I rarely got the appointment within the three or six months that the consultant requested.
The GP diabetic clinic was very different. In those early days the GP made a double appointment at a time when they did not have a surgery. These were very relaxed and concentrated more on how I felt I was coping with living with diabetes rather than the obsession with numbers shown by the consultant at the hospital. Conveniently, if the hospital required a blood test I could have the blood taken at my GP rather than the hospital. At the hospital there were always long waits and I would have to pay for parking. The GP surgery was a short walk from where I lived and the queue for blood tests was always short.
During this time my treatment changed again: I was changed to analogue short acting insulin. This was a disaster. My control went haywire and I put on about 15Kg. Eventually my wife told me I had to change back to the human insulin. I did and my control returned, but I was still somewhat wary since I had changed my treatment without the consultant's permission. In fact, at the next appointment the consultant merely said "no one else seems to have had a problem" and that was it.
In the new millennium things changed. The hospital started to be better funded and it got a loan from the Department of Health so the outpatients department was completed and the whole hospital redecorated. There was a new A&E department and the eye clinic got a new waiting room, and had had contrasting paintwork and signs in letters large enough to read when your eyes are dilated. The hospital was no longer dilapidated.
Since that time I have never sat in a full waiting room and appointments are always prompt. It has been a decade since I last heard a nurse explain that appointments are delayed because of an emergency case. Yet during this time I have been an emergency case myself - I phoned the eye clinic having suffered a haemorrhage in my eye and was told to go immediately to the clinic where I was seen.
But there are other differences. Now I cannot book an appointment at the clinic, instead the appointment is sent to me. I guess this is in response to the 18 week target so that the hospital can change clinics quickly. However, it is a real pain because you cannot guarantee that the appointment letter will get to you before the appointment: one housebound neighbour got an appointment through the post two hours after the appointment time. If you need to change an appointment then you have to phone up and inevitably you get an appointment later than the original, extending the time between clinics. The hospital also seems to regard appointments as easily moveable and often I will get a letter saying that "due to unforeseen circumstances, your appointment has had to be changed". During the time my eyes were unstable (I was told they could haemorrhage at any time) the consultant said he wanted to see me every three months, but the appointment system never took this into account. On one occasion I had three letters changing the appointment, the final one giving me a date 14 months after my last appointment (I phoned, and was given a "cancellation", but the system should not allow an appointment to be made that contradicted the clinician's opinion by so much).
My treatment also changed. First, I was put on an ACE inhibitor by the hospital. Next my long acting (basal) insulin was changed to an analogue, and after using it for twoi years I changed it back to the human insulin, again, because my control had deteriorated on the analogue. In addition, my GP put me on statins, and at a later stage, a calcium channel blocker when my blood pressure had shown it was rising from the recommended value. The ACE inhibitor, calcium channel blocker and statins are all preventative medicines. My cholesterol and blood pressure have been normal for most of my life (sometimes, from their reaction, I used to think that this disappointed the clinicians) but latterly my test results have veered off the recommended range for a diabetic and so I was prescribed the medicines.
With the appointment system aside, the hospital has improved immensely over the last ten years. The GP clinic has gone in the opposite direction. First to go was the ability to have blood taken for a hospital clinic. I was told that since the GP paid for the phlebotomist they would only draw blood for the tests the GP ordered. This now meant that for the blood test for the hospital (to be done two weeks before an appointment) I would have to travel to the hospital. Since there was no co-ordination between the GP and hospital, I would sometimes have a blood test for both within a few weeks - they would not share the results.
Then the diabetic clinic changed to a single appointment during surgery time, so now I had longer waits because my diabetic appointment was treated like any other GP appointment. After a while the diabetic clinic changed again, this time it was the practice nurse took them, not a GP. I learned fairly early on not to ask questions, because if I did, the nurse would say "you should make an appointment and ask the doctor". This surprised me because the diabetic nurse at the hospital was very knowledgeable, she knew far more about living with diabetes (including the various insulin pens and blood testing kits) than the doctors. The GP practice nurse was there merely to measure me.
This coincided with my GP (who ran the original clinics) taking time off for a lengthy illness, and then taking early retirement. However, when I went to another GP about a diabetes related issue he told me that none of the GPs were now specialised in diabetes telling me: "I really should do something about that". As I write this, the GP clinic still hasn't got a doctor who specialises in diabetes. Finally, at my last GP diabetes clinic, the practice nurse told me that they have lost a member of staff (I assume this means a cutback) and so rather than seeing me twice a year (to monitor my condition) they would see me once a year.
This tale has shown a progression of the treatment over time. Initially my diabetes was treated by a hospital consultant and both my GP and I never wanted to contradict what he said. Then during the fundholding period my GP wanted to do everything he could. After that I moved to split care and I found a level of assertiveness about my care. During this time my hospital care got better, but my GP care got worse. First my GP wanted to see me, then she was replace by a practice nurse, and now I am seeing the practice nurse less often, the next stage is surely me not being seen at all by my GP practice.
The government tell us that an important part of their "reforms" is self treatment. This is a nonsense. If you are a diabetic you cannot live without self treatment. It is a 24x7 condition and if you do not treat it, you die. The government implies that I, as a diabetic, am not treating my diabetes well enough, presumably because I am costing them too much. They do not understand that my incentive to have good control of my condition is to feel well. I do not even want to live longer, I just want to feel well, and because of that I am proactive in my own treatment. However, I know why the government wants to involve me more in "self treatment": they want to cut costs. The government does not have a measure of how well I feel, but they do have a measure of how much I cost them.
Self treatment is a natural end point in the relentless journey that is to "move care from hospitals to the community". The "community", ultimately, is the patient. The question is whether the move to self treatment will result in diabetics losing their control and costing the NHS more.
Appointments took a couple of hours because other than the consultation with the paediatrician there was also a trip to the pathology department to have several tubes of blood taken which were then tested for the following appointment (later on, finger prick tests - or more accurately finger jabs because they cut a wide hole in my finger - were introduced so I would have one of those as well as having blood removed from my arm). After leaving the hospital there was always a trip to the cake shop to make up for the blood tests (remember, this was the 70s). Although I do remember it taking time to go between various appointments in the hospital (as well as the blood tests) I do not remember waiting long to be seen.
When I reached 16, I was moved to the adult diabetic clinic in the same hospital where I was seen by a diabetes consultant. The adult clinic that was held in outpatients which was in one of the 70s buildings. To a 16 year old the adult diabetes clinic was a shock. My impression was that diabetes was a condition of the elderly and I was somewhat weird that I had an old people's disease. There must have been teenagers (or even middle aged people) who attended that clinic, but I never saw them, it was the old people I saw.
One distinct memory is queuing up for disposable needles at the hospital pharmacy. I had a glass syringe and so-called reusable needles. However, these blunted quickly which caused scaring and fat to disappear from my injection sites (30 years on, I still have lumps in my thighs from using reusable needles). Part of the problem was the impure insulin. When I was first diagnosed I took bovine insulin and after a few years I moved to porcine insulin; the hospital also started prescribing disposable needles. My control was much better on the porcine insulin, but since this was around the time I started using disposable needles I don't know if the improvement was due to the needles or the insulin. However, one thing is for sure, disposable needles made injecting quite a lot less unpleasant. I could not get disposable needles from my community pharmacy because GPs were not allowed to prescribe them (I was told: because of the cost), so I had to wait for a hospital appointment to get them.
My memories of the hospital adult clinic was not of gleaming floors, instead it was of long waits in waiting rooms full of old, ill people. I distinctly remember peeling paint everywhere.
During this time I had the same GP. She had a very much "hands off" attitude and since (other than the diabetes) I was healthy I never saw her. She did, however, make one of the best recommendations I received soon after I was diagnosed: she gave my mother the address of another family with a child my age who had diabetes. We learned a lot more about living with diabetes from that family than we did from any of the clinicians we talked to. Since diabetes is 24x7 and you can never "cure" it, learning to live with the condition is vital.
When I went to university (and later, when I got a job in the city where I had studied), I went to the hospital diabetic clinic (conveniently at the university hospital). The clinic was only for people of my age: young adults, and discovered that I was not the only young person with the condition. The university hospital was newly built and modern. There was none of that light blue paint that seemed to be used everywhere in the hospital I attended when younger. Instead, there was light wood everywhere and they even had carpeted floors in the clinic. My appointments were always on time, this (and the location - I could get to the diabetic clinic from the university department where I studied via a short cut through the medical school) meant that I could attend the clinic without missing much lecture time. I do remember being seen more often than not by registrars - perhaps an attribute of a teaching hospital - who were mostly female and not much older than me. (Yes, I was a young man, I paid close attention to such things.) After graduating I got a job at the university, so again, it was convenient to take little more than an hour off to attend a clinic.
My treatment changed over this period. When I started at university I used disposable syringes (the needles were attached) and porcine insulin. After a couple of years I moved to human insulin and then after I graduated I changed to using a pen. The first insulin pens would deliver two units of insulin per click, since I had a big dose (around 20) it would mean clicking the pen multiple times making sure I remembered how many. On one occasion I went out to dinner with some work friends and just before the food appeared I went into the toilets to inject. I remember hearing the characteristic click-click-click of an insulin pen from the stall next door and was surprised to discover that it was the technician who worked for me in my lab. I had known him for two years and I didn't know he was diabetic, nor he know that I was.
Again, my GP had a "hands off" approach: the treatment of diabetes was the consultant's responsibility, although I did find that when I occasionally went to my GP he would point out that there was a connection between the condition I presented and my diabetes (usually the fact that my blood sugar was too high). My only contact was the regular request for prescriptions.
A decade later, married with a child, I moved house to follow my job. I registered with the local GP and at my first appointment I asked to be referred to the local hospital. "We don't refer patients to the hospital clinic: we have our own diabetic clinic". I had registered at a fundholding practice although I did not know what this meant. At the first diabetic clinic the doctor told me that he had just been on a course about diabetes. Was this supposed to reassure me by telling me how up-to-date his knowledge was? I don't know, but his next statement dismissed that reassurance: "... but since you've had diabetes for 17 years I think you know more about diabetes than me!" Oh dear.
The practice was a new build and close to my home. However, I worked half an hour's drive away (coincidentally, where I worked was a ten minute walk to the local hospital). Since diabetic clinics were during my working hours it meant that if I had a diabetic clinic I would have to take the morning off work. From memory, appointments were prompt, possibly because it was a new venture for the practice and they had given it more than enough resources. Since I did not see the doctor other than for my diabetes (at this point my control was much better due to the modern insulin I was taking) I do not know how long a patient would wait for a GP appointment.
To be fair to the doctor in the GP clinic, he did notice when there were changes in my eyes and he immediately referred me to the local hospital for laser treatment. This was like going back in time: the hospital was pre-war and some of it was Victorian. My memories are of long waits sitting on plastic chairs in corridors. The eye clinic did emergency work so often I would see someone lead in (or pushed in on a wheelchair) with bandaged eyes and then told my appointment would be delayed as they treated the emergency case. The clinic was just ten minutes walk from where I worked, but the long periods of time I spent waiting for appointments meant I would have to take an afternoon off work. Treatment during week days have a knock-on effect. I taught week long courses and it was not convenient for me to take a morning off halfway through the course, but if I was given an appointment for treatment I had no option, I had to attend on that particular day for fear of not being able to get an alternative date.
Then I changed jobs and moved house (now with another child). The town had two GP practices with surgeries 100m of each other. Both were modern buildings and since there was not much difference between them, we chose more or less at random. At my first GP clinic I told the GP that I wanted to be referred: this time I decided that I was not going to accept just the GP clinic. The GP said "that's fine, we will put you down as shared care".
So now I was seen by the local hospital clinic and the GP clinic. The contrast was marked. The hospital was largely pre-war and the outpatients was in a large 80s extension that had not been completed. The clinics were crowded, (mostly elderly people) and I never had an appointment on time. In those early days at some point during the afternoon a nurse would announce that the doctor had been called away to attend an emergency and so our appointments were delayed (a diabetic clinic for me was always a case of turn up at 2 and be seen after 5).
Although the outpatients department was new it was still tatty: I guess it had not been repainted since I had been built. The older parts of the hospital were worse. The hospital was made up of several building of various ages and there was a long corridor (a covered walkway) between them. For years it seemed that the hospital had no money to replace broken ceiling panels, so occasionally when walking along that corridor you could see the pipes and wires that were the very guts of the hospital. The eye clinic I attended was in the old part and it was cramped with patients waiting on chairs along a narrow corridor. There was one positive memory: whenever I attended the diabetic or eye clinic I had to take my diary because after my appointment I could make the next appointment and was given a specific time and date. This meant that there was even a possibility of ensuring that the appointment would not be when I was away on holiday, although I rarely got the appointment within the three or six months that the consultant requested.
The GP diabetic clinic was very different. In those early days the GP made a double appointment at a time when they did not have a surgery. These were very relaxed and concentrated more on how I felt I was coping with living with diabetes rather than the obsession with numbers shown by the consultant at the hospital. Conveniently, if the hospital required a blood test I could have the blood taken at my GP rather than the hospital. At the hospital there were always long waits and I would have to pay for parking. The GP surgery was a short walk from where I lived and the queue for blood tests was always short.
During this time my treatment changed again: I was changed to analogue short acting insulin. This was a disaster. My control went haywire and I put on about 15Kg. Eventually my wife told me I had to change back to the human insulin. I did and my control returned, but I was still somewhat wary since I had changed my treatment without the consultant's permission. In fact, at the next appointment the consultant merely said "no one else seems to have had a problem" and that was it.
In the new millennium things changed. The hospital started to be better funded and it got a loan from the Department of Health so the outpatients department was completed and the whole hospital redecorated. There was a new A&E department and the eye clinic got a new waiting room, and had had contrasting paintwork and signs in letters large enough to read when your eyes are dilated. The hospital was no longer dilapidated.
Since that time I have never sat in a full waiting room and appointments are always prompt. It has been a decade since I last heard a nurse explain that appointments are delayed because of an emergency case. Yet during this time I have been an emergency case myself - I phoned the eye clinic having suffered a haemorrhage in my eye and was told to go immediately to the clinic where I was seen.
But there are other differences. Now I cannot book an appointment at the clinic, instead the appointment is sent to me. I guess this is in response to the 18 week target so that the hospital can change clinics quickly. However, it is a real pain because you cannot guarantee that the appointment letter will get to you before the appointment: one housebound neighbour got an appointment through the post two hours after the appointment time. If you need to change an appointment then you have to phone up and inevitably you get an appointment later than the original, extending the time between clinics. The hospital also seems to regard appointments as easily moveable and often I will get a letter saying that "due to unforeseen circumstances, your appointment has had to be changed". During the time my eyes were unstable (I was told they could haemorrhage at any time) the consultant said he wanted to see me every three months, but the appointment system never took this into account. On one occasion I had three letters changing the appointment, the final one giving me a date 14 months after my last appointment (I phoned, and was given a "cancellation", but the system should not allow an appointment to be made that contradicted the clinician's opinion by so much).
My treatment also changed. First, I was put on an ACE inhibitor by the hospital. Next my long acting (basal) insulin was changed to an analogue, and after using it for twoi years I changed it back to the human insulin, again, because my control had deteriorated on the analogue. In addition, my GP put me on statins, and at a later stage, a calcium channel blocker when my blood pressure had shown it was rising from the recommended value. The ACE inhibitor, calcium channel blocker and statins are all preventative medicines. My cholesterol and blood pressure have been normal for most of my life (sometimes, from their reaction, I used to think that this disappointed the clinicians) but latterly my test results have veered off the recommended range for a diabetic and so I was prescribed the medicines.
With the appointment system aside, the hospital has improved immensely over the last ten years. The GP clinic has gone in the opposite direction. First to go was the ability to have blood taken for a hospital clinic. I was told that since the GP paid for the phlebotomist they would only draw blood for the tests the GP ordered. This now meant that for the blood test for the hospital (to be done two weeks before an appointment) I would have to travel to the hospital. Since there was no co-ordination between the GP and hospital, I would sometimes have a blood test for both within a few weeks - they would not share the results.
Then the diabetic clinic changed to a single appointment during surgery time, so now I had longer waits because my diabetic appointment was treated like any other GP appointment. After a while the diabetic clinic changed again, this time it was the practice nurse took them, not a GP. I learned fairly early on not to ask questions, because if I did, the nurse would say "you should make an appointment and ask the doctor". This surprised me because the diabetic nurse at the hospital was very knowledgeable, she knew far more about living with diabetes (including the various insulin pens and blood testing kits) than the doctors. The GP practice nurse was there merely to measure me.
This coincided with my GP (who ran the original clinics) taking time off for a lengthy illness, and then taking early retirement. However, when I went to another GP about a diabetes related issue he told me that none of the GPs were now specialised in diabetes telling me: "I really should do something about that". As I write this, the GP clinic still hasn't got a doctor who specialises in diabetes. Finally, at my last GP diabetes clinic, the practice nurse told me that they have lost a member of staff (I assume this means a cutback) and so rather than seeing me twice a year (to monitor my condition) they would see me once a year.
This tale has shown a progression of the treatment over time. Initially my diabetes was treated by a hospital consultant and both my GP and I never wanted to contradict what he said. Then during the fundholding period my GP wanted to do everything he could. After that I moved to split care and I found a level of assertiveness about my care. During this time my hospital care got better, but my GP care got worse. First my GP wanted to see me, then she was replace by a practice nurse, and now I am seeing the practice nurse less often, the next stage is surely me not being seen at all by my GP practice.
The government tell us that an important part of their "reforms" is self treatment. This is a nonsense. If you are a diabetic you cannot live without self treatment. It is a 24x7 condition and if you do not treat it, you die. The government implies that I, as a diabetic, am not treating my diabetes well enough, presumably because I am costing them too much. They do not understand that my incentive to have good control of my condition is to feel well. I do not even want to live longer, I just want to feel well, and because of that I am proactive in my own treatment. However, I know why the government wants to involve me more in "self treatment": they want to cut costs. The government does not have a measure of how well I feel, but they do have a measure of how much I cost them.
Self treatment is a natural end point in the relentless journey that is to "move care from hospitals to the community". The "community", ultimately, is the patient. The question is whether the move to self treatment will result in diabetics losing their control and costing the NHS more.
Wednesday, 24 August 2011
Cost of diabetes
I am incubating a monumental rant over the government's policy to blame sufferers of long term conditions for the current problems with the NHS (problems which have actually been caused by this government). This rant will have to fester a little more before I will let it out. Until then let me just explain about the cost of diabetes.
IT IS NOT THE COST OF THE DRUGS!
There you go: simple isn't it? Complete idiots think that the cost of diabetes is in the drugs. It isn't, and it only takes a little thought to realise why. When diabetes is well controlled - whether type 1 or type 2 - the patient is a fully functioning member of society, no one will know that they have the condition. Indeed, many colleagues do not know that I have type 1 diabetes. The only visible sign of the condition is me injecting insulin before I eat and I have become adept at doing the injection surreptitiously under the table in restaurants (all you need to do is wait for the food to appear - people naturally spend a couple of minutes inspecting what's on their plate and not at you).
A well controlled diabetic is no different to a non-diabetic when it comes to contributing to GDP. The cost of diabetic drugs is fairly small. NHS Information Centre says that last year it was £725m. There are 2.5m people with diabetes (10% are type 1), so that means less than £300 per person.
I have written before that the cost of the drugs I take is small - a few quid a day. However, I only listed the insulin that I must take. I also take other medicine which are preventative: statins and two types of hypertension drugs one of which I am told protects me from kidney damage. These drugs cost pennies per day. The fact that they are preventative is very important because the real cost of diabetes is the cost of the complications from poor control. Long term high blood sugar leads to blindness, nerve damage (leading to amputations), kidney damage (needing dialysis or transplant) and cardiovascular disease. This is where the cost lies. Secondary to this cost of treatment is the monitoring once you show signs of a complication to determine when intervention is needed.
For example I have retinopathy where the blood vessels on my retina are weak and liable to burst. Since this was diagnosed 20 years ago I have had retina clinic appointments every 6 months. I have also had many tens of thousands of laser burns on my retinas to try and prevent vessels growing too big and when one did, and burst, I had an operation where the gel in my eye was removed, my retina cleaned of the bleed and the vessel sealed. That operation lead to me getting a cataract, so I have had cataract operations too. These interventions cost many tens of thousands of pounds: as I said, it is the complications that cost.
Incidentally, for the last 5 years I have been subject to "patient choice". Every six months my GP and my local optician send me a letter telling me that I need to have my retinas screened. Every six months I politely phone them up and tell they to take me off their marketing lists because I am seen every six months by a consultant at the hospital retina clinic. (I don't want to upset GPs or opticians, but honestly, do you really think you know more about my retinas than the specialist at the hospital?) Neither the GP, nor the optician, have shown any sign of removing me from their marketing list. Beware, AQP will open the floodgates to far more companies touting for business like this.
Today the NHS Information Centre published figures of the cost of diabetic drugs. Inevitably these figures have been misreported.
IT IS NOT THE COST OF THE DRUGS!
There you go: simple isn't it? Complete idiots think that the cost of diabetes is in the drugs. It isn't, and it only takes a little thought to realise why. When diabetes is well controlled - whether type 1 or type 2 - the patient is a fully functioning member of society, no one will know that they have the condition. Indeed, many colleagues do not know that I have type 1 diabetes. The only visible sign of the condition is me injecting insulin before I eat and I have become adept at doing the injection surreptitiously under the table in restaurants (all you need to do is wait for the food to appear - people naturally spend a couple of minutes inspecting what's on their plate and not at you).
A well controlled diabetic is no different to a non-diabetic when it comes to contributing to GDP. The cost of diabetic drugs is fairly small. NHS Information Centre says that last year it was £725m. There are 2.5m people with diabetes (10% are type 1), so that means less than £300 per person.
I have written before that the cost of the drugs I take is small - a few quid a day. However, I only listed the insulin that I must take. I also take other medicine which are preventative: statins and two types of hypertension drugs one of which I am told protects me from kidney damage. These drugs cost pennies per day. The fact that they are preventative is very important because the real cost of diabetes is the cost of the complications from poor control. Long term high blood sugar leads to blindness, nerve damage (leading to amputations), kidney damage (needing dialysis or transplant) and cardiovascular disease. This is where the cost lies. Secondary to this cost of treatment is the monitoring once you show signs of a complication to determine when intervention is needed.
For example I have retinopathy where the blood vessels on my retina are weak and liable to burst. Since this was diagnosed 20 years ago I have had retina clinic appointments every 6 months. I have also had many tens of thousands of laser burns on my retinas to try and prevent vessels growing too big and when one did, and burst, I had an operation where the gel in my eye was removed, my retina cleaned of the bleed and the vessel sealed. That operation lead to me getting a cataract, so I have had cataract operations too. These interventions cost many tens of thousands of pounds: as I said, it is the complications that cost.
Incidentally, for the last 5 years I have been subject to "patient choice". Every six months my GP and my local optician send me a letter telling me that I need to have my retinas screened. Every six months I politely phone them up and tell they to take me off their marketing lists because I am seen every six months by a consultant at the hospital retina clinic. (I don't want to upset GPs or opticians, but honestly, do you really think you know more about my retinas than the specialist at the hospital?) Neither the GP, nor the optician, have shown any sign of removing me from their marketing list. Beware, AQP will open the floodgates to far more companies touting for business like this.
Today the NHS Information Centre published figures of the cost of diabetic drugs. Inevitably these figures have been misreported.
Diabetes prescriptions now account for 8.4 per cent of the entire NHS net bill for primary care drugs in England.These drugs - if used correctly - will prevent a large range of complications and hence reduce demand on the NHS in the future. We should not focus on the cost of these drugs now, and instead we should focus on the cost of diabetes if we didn't spend this money.
Choice and Competition
Can choice and competition work in the NHS?
NHS funding is being cut so is it economic to have a choice over everything? Choice costs. For example, if you choose the exact day (and time of day) to have your cataract replaced, the provider has to have a timeslot available for you to choose it. The provider cannot guess what time you will choose and consequently to plan ahead (and ensure there will be the staff and theatre time) they have to provide over-capacity. They also have to have over-capacity to accommodate patients who switch providers, again, something they cannot accurately predict. This over-capacity means that more facilities and staff will have to be available than is actually needed, and this has a cost.
In their evaluation of the London Patient Choice project, Picker Institute says:
The LPCP is used as"evidence" that patients want choice because in the project two thirds of patients offered chose took up the offer. However, when you look at the details, it is more surprising that a third did not take up choice. The reason is that in the project patients were given access to Patient Care Advisers (these are not available to current NHS patients) to help them have all the information they need to make a choice; they were also given free transport to the alternative hospital (one patient even chose to go to an overseas hospital). But crucially, the patients who took part in LPCP were had already waited over six months. It is rather surprising that anyone would not take up the offer to join a shorter queue, but a third did.
Two facts: the patients involved had waited more than 6 months and the hospitals involved in the pilot were given funds to increase their capacity. This raises the question: if the hospitals had been given the extra funding before the pilot, would this have prevented patients waiting more than 6 months and hence removed their desire to choose to use another hospital?
In a totally free market there are ways to fiddle such a system to make it more efficient. I used to work in computer training and when I started the job I looked at the company's brochure and noticed that the week-long courses I gave (I was the only trainer of those subjects) were often in two cities on the same day. I pointed this out to my manager and he replied that I would give the course that had the most customers, the customers who had booked for the other city would be told that "their course was full" and be given a discount to attend the course in the city where I would be. This system meant that during the year I worked for that company I never had a week when I was not training (from the numbers of people I trained, I estimate that the company took in £250,000 training fees; not bad considering that by the time I resigned I was on £23,000).
The problem is that the free-at-the-point-of-use system is not a free market, so it is not possible to use a discount to persuade a patient to choose another time. So if we have real choice of providers those providers must run at excess capacity. The cost of this over capacity is money that could be spent on more healthcare, and as we suffer more rationing (that no one voted for) there will be political pressure for providers to cut costs. My guess is that commissioners, recognising that the unpredictability of patient choice is a major source of inefficiency and will quietly remove patient choice.
[On Twitter I suggested using bed occupancy as a measure of this over capacity. Unfortunately health policy wonks misunderstood the point I was making and veered off in another direction saying that the number of beds in NHS hospitals are reducing. So what? AQP has not started in earnest yet and this reduction is being driven by NHS cost cutting.]
It is also often stated that "choice" improves quality. Again, I think that this is not possible. Looking through the board papers of my local hospital I see that a consultant has been asked to leave. The reason is the high number of letters of complaints about his attitude to patients (interestingly, not his clinical ability). The hospital did not count the number of patients using that clinic and use that data to decide whether to sack the "low quality" clinician. Of course not, there is a waiting list so that means there are already too many patients (d'oh!). Patient complaints raised the quality of that clinic, not patient choice.
If I get a poor service from, say, my GP and I decide to register with another GP, will that raise the quality of my previous GP? No, of course not, I am merely one patient. Do I now want to raise the quality of my previous GP? I have a new GP who I am happy with so the quality of the old GP is of no interest to me - why should I care? Of course, over time there may be other patients who decide to move away from that GP, but the important point is that it is over a length of time. It may take months or years before a threshold is reached when the practice realises that that particular GP is simply not popular. During this time more patients will get a poor service. Is it acceptable to allow patients to have a poor service over a long time?
The Competition and Co-operation Panel produced a report earlier this year on Any Willing Provider. In this they give the following graph as their "proof" that choice raises quality:
They say:
During those few months when the referrals declined staff will still have been employed, adding to the trust's costs, and since many electives are paid through payment-by-results there would be no income for the lost patients. So the hospital will make a loss due to this bad publicity. This is hardly the best way to invest in better quality.
Competition and choice are extremely blunt tools. When it comes to healthcare we are right to demand the best, and to get this every provider must be of high quality. Do we really want to stake our lives on blunt, largely ineffectual mechanisms to raise quality? I think not.
NHS funding is being cut so is it economic to have a choice over everything? Choice costs. For example, if you choose the exact day (and time of day) to have your cataract replaced, the provider has to have a timeslot available for you to choose it. The provider cannot guess what time you will choose and consequently to plan ahead (and ensure there will be the staff and theatre time) they have to provide over-capacity. They also have to have over-capacity to accommodate patients who switch providers, again, something they cannot accurately predict. This over-capacity means that more facilities and staff will have to be available than is actually needed, and this has a cost.
In their evaluation of the London Patient Choice project, Picker Institute says:
"Choice is dependent on the availability of beds and staff, so providers were encouraged to expand capacity and improve the management of existing resources to enable patients to exercise choice. Funds were made available for this purpose and several treatment centres specialising in elective surgical procedures (e.g. hip and knee replacements or cataract operations) were established."The important point here is that hospitals taking part in this programme were given funds to create the extra capacity. Patient choice is not possible without this capacity, nor the funds to provide it.
The LPCP is used as"evidence" that patients want choice because in the project two thirds of patients offered chose took up the offer. However, when you look at the details, it is more surprising that a third did not take up choice. The reason is that in the project patients were given access to Patient Care Advisers (these are not available to current NHS patients) to help them have all the information they need to make a choice; they were also given free transport to the alternative hospital (one patient even chose to go to an overseas hospital). But crucially, the patients who took part in LPCP were had already waited over six months. It is rather surprising that anyone would not take up the offer to join a shorter queue, but a third did.
Two facts: the patients involved had waited more than 6 months and the hospitals involved in the pilot were given funds to increase their capacity. This raises the question: if the hospitals had been given the extra funding before the pilot, would this have prevented patients waiting more than 6 months and hence removed their desire to choose to use another hospital?
In a totally free market there are ways to fiddle such a system to make it more efficient. I used to work in computer training and when I started the job I looked at the company's brochure and noticed that the week-long courses I gave (I was the only trainer of those subjects) were often in two cities on the same day. I pointed this out to my manager and he replied that I would give the course that had the most customers, the customers who had booked for the other city would be told that "their course was full" and be given a discount to attend the course in the city where I would be. This system meant that during the year I worked for that company I never had a week when I was not training (from the numbers of people I trained, I estimate that the company took in £250,000 training fees; not bad considering that by the time I resigned I was on £23,000).
The problem is that the free-at-the-point-of-use system is not a free market, so it is not possible to use a discount to persuade a patient to choose another time. So if we have real choice of providers those providers must run at excess capacity. The cost of this over capacity is money that could be spent on more healthcare, and as we suffer more rationing (that no one voted for) there will be political pressure for providers to cut costs. My guess is that commissioners, recognising that the unpredictability of patient choice is a major source of inefficiency and will quietly remove patient choice.
[On Twitter I suggested using bed occupancy as a measure of this over capacity. Unfortunately health policy wonks misunderstood the point I was making and veered off in another direction saying that the number of beds in NHS hospitals are reducing. So what? AQP has not started in earnest yet and this reduction is being driven by NHS cost cutting.]
It is also often stated that "choice" improves quality. Again, I think that this is not possible. Looking through the board papers of my local hospital I see that a consultant has been asked to leave. The reason is the high number of letters of complaints about his attitude to patients (interestingly, not his clinical ability). The hospital did not count the number of patients using that clinic and use that data to decide whether to sack the "low quality" clinician. Of course not, there is a waiting list so that means there are already too many patients (d'oh!). Patient complaints raised the quality of that clinic, not patient choice.
If I get a poor service from, say, my GP and I decide to register with another GP, will that raise the quality of my previous GP? No, of course not, I am merely one patient. Do I now want to raise the quality of my previous GP? I have a new GP who I am happy with so the quality of the old GP is of no interest to me - why should I care? Of course, over time there may be other patients who decide to move away from that GP, but the important point is that it is over a length of time. It may take months or years before a threshold is reached when the practice realises that that particular GP is simply not popular. During this time more patients will get a poor service. Is it acceptable to allow patients to have a poor service over a long time?
The Competition and Co-operation Panel produced a report earlier this year on Any Willing Provider. In this they give the following graph as their "proof" that choice raises quality:
They say:
"adverse news about the quality of care at a particular hospital can also have a significant short-term impact on patient referral patterns. For example, in early 2010, shortly after the CQC’s findings of ‘systematic failings’ at Basildon and Thurrock NHS FT was publicly reported, there was a short, sharp decline in patient referrals for routine elective care"Fine, there was a "short, sharp decline" but this is no proof that quality has changed at Basildon and Thurrock: after a couple of months patients returned! Why did they return? Well the CCP tells you clearly in the title of the graph "change in patient referrals for routine elective care following adverse publicity over quality standards", that is, once the publicity stopped, the patients returned, they didn't return because quality improved.
During those few months when the referrals declined staff will still have been employed, adding to the trust's costs, and since many electives are paid through payment-by-results there would be no income for the lost patients. So the hospital will make a loss due to this bad publicity. This is hardly the best way to invest in better quality.
Competition and choice are extremely blunt tools. When it comes to healthcare we are right to demand the best, and to get this every provider must be of high quality. Do we really want to stake our lives on blunt, largely ineffectual mechanisms to raise quality? I think not.
Thursday, 11 August 2011
What we teach our kids
We do not teach our kids to work hard, to develop their abilities and be good at what they do. Instead, we teach our kids that the best way to the top is to trample on weaker people. We are told that competition is king, yet for every winner it creates it produces a large pile of losers. We tell our kids that the only way to improve themselves is through a long list of beaten competitors. It is a bankrupt philosophy for a bankrupt country.
Over the last three decades we have seen the rise of predatory private equity funds, companies whose sole aim is short term asset stripping. They treat company pensions as an asset of the company, an asset that they can exploit, rather than the future of the staff. They have a short term attitude that the sum of the parts is more than the value of the whole. They break up companies for an immediate profit even when the long term profitability of the company is better when left intact. How can we teach our kids that working hard is important, when we see that the reward for that work can be exploited by predatory private equity, buying up your employer, stealing your pension and making you redundant?
Small companies are being brought to the brink of bankruptcy when the larger companies they supply decide to change payment terms so that invoices are paid months later than before. The large companies do this because they can. How can we teach our kids fairness, when businesses behave in such underhanded ways merely because their size allows them to be bullies?
And now the government is doing the same thing. We are told that Monitor exists to stop "anti-competitive behaviour" and in the Open Public Services white paper we are told that companies will have a right to challenge commissioners over the provision of public services. We see that even if a public provider is doing a good job, providing a service that the public want and appreciate, it may lose its contract to provide the service simply because a private company says that it would like to provide the service instead. How can we teach our kids that if they work hard and become the best they will be rewarded, when the government says the reward for hard work in public services is for a private company to take over the service, employ fewer staff and pay them less?
We see people making vast amounts of money by simply moving money around. Hedge funds and investment banks make nothing, they simply take money from one place (perhaps invested in company stock) and move it to somewhere else (perhaps government bonds) and then, when the time is right, move it back again. No hard graft, no innovation, no product made and sold; just moving money around and making vast amounts of money doing it. We see that one favoured way of making money – short selling – borders on dishonesty: the short seller sells a security they do not own hoping that they can buy it back at a lower price before they have to return it to the lender. we see the effect of short selling for profit as it devalues companies and the pension funds - our pensions! - holding the stock. How can we teach our kids honesty, when short sellers show that so much money can be made by selling things you do not own?
It's about time we started teaching our kids correctly: that hard work and using our abilities is rewarding. But for our kids to believe us that this is true they have to see results that prove the assertion, and we have to prove that doing otherwise is not rewarding. Sadly, hard work does and will continue to result in stress, poor pay and poor conditions leaving us open to exploitation. The government's plans to reduce our state pensions (or make us pay more for smaller public service pensions), and their plans to ration our healthcare when we are in our old age, shows that they do not acknowledge that hard work should pay. We should have used the financial crisis to rid ourselves of the high rewarding something-for-nothing occupations, but we've flunked it and it will take another generation before there is an opportunity to try again.
Over the last three decades we have seen the rise of predatory private equity funds, companies whose sole aim is short term asset stripping. They treat company pensions as an asset of the company, an asset that they can exploit, rather than the future of the staff. They have a short term attitude that the sum of the parts is more than the value of the whole. They break up companies for an immediate profit even when the long term profitability of the company is better when left intact. How can we teach our kids that working hard is important, when we see that the reward for that work can be exploited by predatory private equity, buying up your employer, stealing your pension and making you redundant?
Small companies are being brought to the brink of bankruptcy when the larger companies they supply decide to change payment terms so that invoices are paid months later than before. The large companies do this because they can. How can we teach our kids fairness, when businesses behave in such underhanded ways merely because their size allows them to be bullies?
And now the government is doing the same thing. We are told that Monitor exists to stop "anti-competitive behaviour" and in the Open Public Services white paper we are told that companies will have a right to challenge commissioners over the provision of public services. We see that even if a public provider is doing a good job, providing a service that the public want and appreciate, it may lose its contract to provide the service simply because a private company says that it would like to provide the service instead. How can we teach our kids that if they work hard and become the best they will be rewarded, when the government says the reward for hard work in public services is for a private company to take over the service, employ fewer staff and pay them less?
We see people making vast amounts of money by simply moving money around. Hedge funds and investment banks make nothing, they simply take money from one place (perhaps invested in company stock) and move it to somewhere else (perhaps government bonds) and then, when the time is right, move it back again. No hard graft, no innovation, no product made and sold; just moving money around and making vast amounts of money doing it. We see that one favoured way of making money – short selling – borders on dishonesty: the short seller sells a security they do not own hoping that they can buy it back at a lower price before they have to return it to the lender. we see the effect of short selling for profit as it devalues companies and the pension funds - our pensions! - holding the stock. How can we teach our kids honesty, when short sellers show that so much money can be made by selling things you do not own?
It's about time we started teaching our kids correctly: that hard work and using our abilities is rewarding. But for our kids to believe us that this is true they have to see results that prove the assertion, and we have to prove that doing otherwise is not rewarding. Sadly, hard work does and will continue to result in stress, poor pay and poor conditions leaving us open to exploitation. The government's plans to reduce our state pensions (or make us pay more for smaller public service pensions), and their plans to ration our healthcare when we are in our old age, shows that they do not acknowledge that hard work should pay. We should have used the financial crisis to rid ourselves of the high rewarding something-for-nothing occupations, but we've flunked it and it will take another generation before there is an opportunity to try again.
Wednesday, 10 August 2011
Rank Hypocrisy
Last year the government issued all Coalition MPs with a list of stock answers that they could parrot when asked about Lansley's NHS re-organisation. The government listed what they called "myths" and gave the government's response to each. It is now becoming apparent that most of these "myths" are going to happen. Take for example "Myth 6" and "Myth 7":
GPs are rightly concerned, Pulse reports:
Where are the Coalition MPs who blindly parroted the Coalition line at the beginning of this year? How can they vote for the Health and Social Care Bill at the Report Stage at the beginning of September now that the hypocrisy of the government is abundantly clear?
I have addressed most of these "myths" on my other site NHS Futures (including "Myth 6" and "Myth 7").
UPDATE
The government's response to the Future Forum says:
Myth 6 GP consortia will be forced to use the private sector
Fact
It will be up to GP consortia to decide their own arrangements.
Myth 7 Every NHS service will need to be competitively tendered.First, let's address "Myth 7". The government claims that services will not be competitive tendered and that patients will be able to choose "any willing provider". However, we learn today from Pulse that:
Fact
Our plans for ‘any willing provider’ are precisely the opposite. Competitive tendering means identifying a single provider to offer a service exclusively. ‘Any willing provider’ means being clear that a service needs to meet NHS standards and NHS costs, and then allowing patients to choose themselves wherever they want to be treated. It is designed to avoid the need for costly tendering processes, unlike Labour’s ‘independent sector treatment centres’.
"NHS East of England plans to auction off £300m of services to GPs, private companies or a combination of the two, in pathways including respiratory and musculoskeletal medicine."There is no patient choice at all, once these services have been outsourced patients will have to use them. This is simple, unadulterated privatisation of these services (showing that "Myth 6" is true, GPs will have to use the private sector) through competitive tendering ("Myth 7" is true because these services are being "auctioned off").
GPs are rightly concerned, Pulse reports:
"Dr Brian Balmer, chief executive of Essex LMCs and a GP in Chelmsford, said: ‘A lot of our GP commissioners don't know anything about these plans. The SHA's commercial wing these days is very, very ambitious. They are keen to be the first to do these dramatic things that could see us turn into an American-style health service that we can't afford and that will harm patients.'"
Where are the Coalition MPs who blindly parroted the Coalition line at the beginning of this year? How can they vote for the Health and Social Care Bill at the Report Stage at the beginning of September now that the hypocrisy of the government is abundantly clear?
I have addressed most of these "myths" on my other site NHS Futures (including "Myth 6" and "Myth 7").
UPDATE
The government's response to the Future Forum says:
"Therefore, we will outlaw any policy to increase or maintain the market share of any particular sector of provider. This will prevent current or future Ministers, the NHS Commissioning Board or Monitor from having a deliberate policy of encouraging the growth of the private sector over existing state providers – or vice versa."So if East of England plans to increase the proportion of private sector providers in care pathways, that will contravene the statement to "outlaw any policy to increase or maintain the market share of any particular sector ... prevent ... a deliberate policy of encouraging the growth of the private sector". What is Lansley doing about East of England's auction?
Saturday, 6 August 2011
Our safety at stake in Lala land?
The 999 service is a lifeline to all for us, but in healthcare the ambulance service is expensive and open to abuse. Such abuse is often not intentional, how do you know whether your condition is an emergency? You are not trained to make such triage decisions. According to the NHS Information Centre the ambulance service receives almost 8 million 999 calls per year of which 2.5 million (32%) are classified as urgent rather than emergency and 37% of Emergency Department attendances are classed as "minor" problems. Clearly there is a potential issue that non-emergency calls are delaying access to emergency calls, and their is an issue of cost.
This is the reason for NHS Direct, if there is any doubt whether the condition is an emergency, you can call 08454647 (remember that number!) and a trained clinician will advise you. Of course NHS Direct is more than that, their clinicians will advise you on less urgent conditions too: support for patients with long-term conditions, pre and post operative support for patients and help and advice during health scares (like swine flu). Their primary aim is to give you advice which will ultimately mean that the NHS will work more efficiently and effectively by making sure that you get the most appropriate treatment.
NHS Direct was always intended to be an initial solution, and in 2009 the previous government commissioned pilots to extend the service with closer integration with urgent care providers and to use a software system called NHS Pathways. This new system was piloted in four areas of England to assess the effectiveness against NHS Direct. In 2010 the new government - before the assessments were completed - announced that the new NHS 111 service would be rolled out to the entire country. Sadly, this service is yet another one that the government wants to privatise by opening up to other providers.
Last year there was a fuss when it became apparent that the government wanted to close NHS Direct, and as a result of the outrage the service was given a reprieve. But like everything with this weasel government, the "reprieve" was only partial because the government merely said that NHS Direct would be expected to be just one of several providers of the new NHS 111 service. Yes, that is right, the government thinks that there has to be competition. Bizarre? Indeed. We live in Lala land ruled by people who think that nothing can work without enforced and inappropriate competition. My anger is not just with the government, Labour has accepted this situation: they thought the reprieve was a result. In fact it was a result: it was exactly what the government wanted, you cannot have competition without competitors and NHS Direct is, and always was intended to be, one of the competitors in this contrived competition.
Let's just look at the headline issue. After April 2013, the 08454647 number (did you remember it?) will be replaced with the 111 number (in the government's documents referred to using the management-speak as 3DN or a "3 digit number"). The government is making a big thing about this, and for good reason, why was NHS Direct given the entirely forgettable 08454647 number in the first place? In fact the policy to replace 08454647 with 111 is not Lansley's bright idea anyway (he does not have bright ideas) the last government intended to make the change too (as this document from OFCOM in July 2009 shows). I will leave it up to the conspiracy theorists as to why the Department of Health under Labour chose to allow NHS Direct to be created with a number that was not fit for purpose. However, the difference between a Labour government replacing NHS Direct with a 111 service and a Conservative government doing this is not simply the number (nor the new services that NHS 111 will deliver), it is who will provide the service. Lansley says that there has to be competition over who will provide the 111 service in your area. Lala land indeed.
How big is each area? Well, it would be plain stupid to make each area the size of the clinical commissioning groups (currently the median population size is 170k, but there are many who cover 100K or less, and one that covers just 14,000). Ultimately, it will be the CCG who will pay for the service and so we are in the bizarre situation that the CCG commissioners will have to pay for a service that they cannot commission individually because they only sensible way to provide the services is with other commissioners that have been contrived. At the moment the 111 services are to be rolled out on a Strategic Health Authority basis, and it is each SHA has to decide ("with full support of local Clinical Commissioning Groups and PCTs") who will provide the service.
Bizarrely, the we will move from the national service of NHS Direct (national: so people are familiar with its services and how to use it) to more localised ones so if you use 111 in a different area you'll have to re-learn what services they have and how to use them. (You, dear reader, may find this trivial, but will everyone? The service has to work with everyone.)
David Flory, Deputy NHS Chief Executive says:
I regularly read the websites of local hospital trusts across the country and the most irritating aspect is that they are all different, with different ways to get the same information. It is an issue for someone with reasonable eyesight, but what about someone with partial sight or no sight (and relies on screen readers)? Why hasn't someone come up with a brilliant idea like a best practice website design that all hospital trusts have to follow? NHS Choices and NHS Direct are both national systems that give a standard way to access their information regardless of where you live in the country. Yet Flory is now suggesting that SHAs can award the NHS 111 service to anyone using any "content or software". This is mandating fragmentation and confusion.
The NHS 111 telephone service will involve many providers to work together to give a single, comprehensive system within your local area. This is not an easy task, especially as we move to an NHS that is driven by competition rather than collaboration. And to make matters worse, Flory is introducing a deadline on awarding the contracts for these local versions of NHS 111 that GPs are calling "crazy". GPOnline says:
This behaviour is symptomatic of this government: fragmentation of a service that currently works (and was developing), privatisation, enforced unworkable deadlines resulting in an implicit designed to fail outcome. If this is happening to the websites of the new NHS 111 services, what will happen to the telephone services and what will be the knock-on effect to the 111 "urgent service" and ultimately the 999 service? Lala land.
(Updated 2011-08-07 after comments on Twitter)
This is the reason for NHS Direct, if there is any doubt whether the condition is an emergency, you can call 08454647 (remember that number!) and a trained clinician will advise you. Of course NHS Direct is more than that, their clinicians will advise you on less urgent conditions too: support for patients with long-term conditions, pre and post operative support for patients and help and advice during health scares (like swine flu). Their primary aim is to give you advice which will ultimately mean that the NHS will work more efficiently and effectively by making sure that you get the most appropriate treatment.
NHS Direct was always intended to be an initial solution, and in 2009 the previous government commissioned pilots to extend the service with closer integration with urgent care providers and to use a software system called NHS Pathways. This new system was piloted in four areas of England to assess the effectiveness against NHS Direct. In 2010 the new government - before the assessments were completed - announced that the new NHS 111 service would be rolled out to the entire country. Sadly, this service is yet another one that the government wants to privatise by opening up to other providers.
Last year there was a fuss when it became apparent that the government wanted to close NHS Direct, and as a result of the outrage the service was given a reprieve. But like everything with this weasel government, the "reprieve" was only partial because the government merely said that NHS Direct would be expected to be just one of several providers of the new NHS 111 service. Yes, that is right, the government thinks that there has to be competition. Bizarre? Indeed. We live in Lala land ruled by people who think that nothing can work without enforced and inappropriate competition. My anger is not just with the government, Labour has accepted this situation: they thought the reprieve was a result. In fact it was a result: it was exactly what the government wanted, you cannot have competition without competitors and NHS Direct is, and always was intended to be, one of the competitors in this contrived competition.
Let's just look at the headline issue. After April 2013, the 08454647 number (did you remember it?) will be replaced with the 111 number (in the government's documents referred to using the management-speak as 3DN or a "3 digit number"). The government is making a big thing about this, and for good reason, why was NHS Direct given the entirely forgettable 08454647 number in the first place? In fact the policy to replace 08454647 with 111 is not Lansley's bright idea anyway (he does not have bright ideas) the last government intended to make the change too (as this document from OFCOM in July 2009 shows). I will leave it up to the conspiracy theorists as to why the Department of Health under Labour chose to allow NHS Direct to be created with a number that was not fit for purpose. However, the difference between a Labour government replacing NHS Direct with a 111 service and a Conservative government doing this is not simply the number (nor the new services that NHS 111 will deliver), it is who will provide the service. Lansley says that there has to be competition over who will provide the 111 service in your area. Lala land indeed.
How big is each area? Well, it would be plain stupid to make each area the size of the clinical commissioning groups (currently the median population size is 170k, but there are many who cover 100K or less, and one that covers just 14,000). Ultimately, it will be the CCG who will pay for the service and so we are in the bizarre situation that the CCG commissioners will have to pay for a service that they cannot commission individually because they only sensible way to provide the services is with other commissioners that have been contrived. At the moment the 111 services are to be rolled out on a Strategic Health Authority basis, and it is each SHA has to decide ("with full support of local Clinical Commissioning Groups and PCTs") who will provide the service.
Bizarrely, the we will move from the national service of NHS Direct (national: so people are familiar with its services and how to use it) to more localised ones so if you use 111 in a different area you'll have to re-learn what services they have and how to use them. (You, dear reader, may find this trivial, but will everyone? The service has to work with everyone.)
David Flory, Deputy NHS Chief Executive says:
"The NHS Operations Board also re-stated the need for commissioners, led by local clinicians, to take the lead in planning for the roll out of NHS 111, and developing a comprehensive directory of services, and associated referral protocols to underpin the service. We should remind you that the Department will not mandate specific content or software for NHS 111. This will be for local commissioners to determine, with appropriate clinical advice and support."Remember that the NHS 111 services (like NHS Direct) will provide both a telephone service and a website. It makes sense to have local clinicians involved in the design of the telephone service since the service will use local providers: ambulance services, out-of-hours services (ie private GP companies who do the service that GPs used to do before the last Labour government privatised this service), GP "in hours" home visits (yet to be privatised as the government's "urgent service") and hospital A&E. But NHS Direct also provides a website with a symptom checker. It makes no sense whatsoever to have separate local websites to do this work, yet that is implicit in Flory's statement that "the Department will not mandate specific content or software for NHS 111".
I regularly read the websites of local hospital trusts across the country and the most irritating aspect is that they are all different, with different ways to get the same information. It is an issue for someone with reasonable eyesight, but what about someone with partial sight or no sight (and relies on screen readers)? Why hasn't someone come up with a brilliant idea like a best practice website design that all hospital trusts have to follow? NHS Choices and NHS Direct are both national systems that give a standard way to access their information regardless of where you live in the country. Yet Flory is now suggesting that SHAs can award the NHS 111 service to anyone using any "content or software". This is mandating fragmentation and confusion.
The NHS 111 telephone service will involve many providers to work together to give a single, comprehensive system within your local area. This is not an easy task, especially as we move to an NHS that is driven by competition rather than collaboration. And to make matters worse, Flory is introducing a deadline on awarding the contracts for these local versions of NHS 111 that GPs are calling "crazy". GPOnline says:
"strategic health authorities have been given seven weeks to tell the DoH how and when they plan to roll-out NHS 111 hotlines across their area ... one senior GP warned the deadline was 'crazy' given that the pilot NHS 111 schemes across the UK were either incomplete, or yet even to begin"
This behaviour is symptomatic of this government: fragmentation of a service that currently works (and was developing), privatisation, enforced unworkable deadlines resulting in an implicit designed to fail outcome. If this is happening to the websites of the new NHS 111 services, what will happen to the telephone services and what will be the knock-on effect to the 111 "urgent service" and ultimately the 999 service? Lala land.
(Updated 2011-08-07 after comments on Twitter)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

