"The NHS will last as long as there are folk left with the faith to fight for it"
Aneurin Bevan

Wednesday, 12 October 2011

Silver lining?

I am a pessimist (some would say a curmudgeon) so the votes in the House of Lords does not surprise me, especially since many of the Tory peers who voted probably had not been in the chamber for years and were voting out of mere loyalty to a political party.

The Bill:
  1. will not save money, quite the opposite, it will cost billions to implement and the bureaucratic structures that have been created will slow down any re-configuration that is needed and will cost a pile of money in the process;
  2. will produce a postcode lottery on a scale that England has never before experienced and as a consequence, health inequalities will increase;
  3. will mean that rationing will be rife and people will find that they have no recourse;
  4. together with the financial squeeze and the wasteful bureaucracy created by the Bill will result in a financial crisis
The time to get ill in England was a decade ago, from now on, you'll find yourself more and more on your own.

One could argue that if Labour had won the election last year the NHS would have faced tightening finances too. Labour promised the same flat funding and also promised the £20bn "efficiency savings". However, Labour did not promise a £2bn re-organisation, but whether this extra £2bn of funding would have been enough to avert the financial crisis the NHS will suffer is something we will never know. The forthcoming financial crisis and the rationing inherent in the Bill will mean that the NHS will be the main issue at the next election.

The government know that there will be a financial crisis in the NHS, and they know that if it is not averted we will see patients on trolleys in corridors. Currently, Lansley is backtracking on NHS finances. At the Health Select Committee yesterday he said that the "efficiency savings" were "up to £20bn" rather than strictly £20bn. This will allow him to relax the "Nicholson Challenge" diktat when it becomes apparent that either the NHS cannot achieve a 4% cut every year, or that cutting so deep will push the service into crisis. Further, Lansley is also suggesting that some hospital trusts may be bailed out, something that the white paper last year said the government would not do.This is being done to make sure that there are not too many trust bankruptcies before the next election. Further - to try and persuade Lib Dem and Crossbench peers to vote against the Owen amendment - the government has conceded that the Secretary of State will have responsibility for the NHS (although we have yet to see the actual details, in particular, whether clause 10 will be removed).

So is there a silver lining? On a purely political basis, there is. From this point on the government cannot say that the state of the NHS is the fault of the last government: by passing this Bill they are making the NHS work their way. If this bill is killed then the Conservatives can say that the NHS that Labour bequeathed was wasteful and inefficient and say that this is why it is suffering a financial crisis.

When the Health and Social Care Bill is passed, the NHS will be Lansley's NHS and any ensuing financial crisis will be entirely the government's fault. At the next election Labour will be able to say to the electorate: look at what the Tories have done to our NHS. And hopefully, Labour will promise to fix the postcode lottery and raise funding to curtail healthcare rationing. We will all benefit.

Monday, 10 October 2011

AQP and Commissioning

On the surface AQP (patient choice) and commissioning are antithetical since commissioning is carried out for a population, whereas patient choice is for the individual. However, the two can be combined. The House of Lords constitutional select committee report on the Secretary of State's duties outlines this:


12.  Clause 10 of the Bill amends section 3(1) of the NHS Act 2006. As amended, section 3(1) would provide as follows:
(1)  A clinical commissioning group [CCG] must arrange for the provision of the following to such extent as it considers necessary to meet the reasonable requirements of the persons for whom it has responsibility—
(a)  hospital accommodation,
(b)  other accommodation for the purpose of any service provided under this Act,
(c)  medical, dental, ophthalmic, nursing and ambulance services, 
etc
In the 2006 Act it is the Secretary of State who has this responsibility. If this clause survives into the Act then CCGs will decide "to such extent as it considers necessary to meet the reasonable requirements of the persons for whom it has responsibility" the medical services in the area. That is, the CCG determines which services the NHS will pay for. So when GPs in Haxby offer private procedures to their patients they are merely jumping the gun: this is what it will be like in most areas after the Bill is passed. The CCG determines the services the NHS will pay for and private providers (including GPs themselves if they have a private business) can offer the services that are not paid by the NHS as private services.

The government's policy document Making Quality Your Business: A guide to the right to provide says:

To qualify as an AQP, providers will be subject to a qualification process. They will be required to show that they can meet the conditions of their licence with CQC and/or Monitor (if necessary), provide safe quality services to the contractual standards set by the NHS Commissioning Board and meet NHS prices – either set nationally or locally.
This is where the Q in AQP comes in, once a provider has met the conditions of CQC and Monitor it becomes an AQP. However, CCGs do have some leverage, the same document goes on to say:
Commissioners (PCTs and consortia) can set reasonable additional contractually binding quality standards to meet the needs of particular communities or patient groups. This could include referral protocols and thresholds to manage demand and support integration with local services. Providers will be expected to work within and as part of the local health system.
(Note that this pre-dates the introduction of the term CCG.) This says that CCGs can insist that AQPs meet the specific needs of their population and hence this is is another part of the Q in AQP and is part of the commissioning that the CCGs will do.

Once AQPs have been licenced (and hence meet the criteria of CQC, Monitor and the CCG) they will be put on the list of providers from which the patients can choose:

Commissioners cannot refuse to accept qualified providers once qualified, unless providers fail quality standards, reject the agreed price or refuse to comply with any reasonable, additional, locally set standards.
GPs cannot tell patients which AQP provider to use and they cannot refuse to add an AQP provider to the list of providers patients can choose from, so any talk of GPs "protecting" NHS providers is fanciful because Monitor will force them to add AQPs to the providers list.

The remaining "commissioning" part of CCGs is determining which services the NHS will pay for. This is clause 10 of the Bill and is also described in the Making Quality your Business policy document:

It will be for commissioners to decide which services are best delivered through an AQP approach or tendering but the presumption will be that for most services patients will have a choice of Any Qualified Provider.
This says that the government says that there should be a presumption that most NHS services will be AQP, but note that the commissioners (CCGs) decide which services are provided.

Saturday, 8 October 2011

Fickle Patients

Earlier this week I wrote for UK Uncut an article about how I think that the government's Any Qualified Provider policy will be the main driver to privatise the NHS. My argument was that the policy will create thousands of new providers who will appear on the Choose and Book system, and when a patient chooses a non-NHS provider that will mean money for their care will go to the new provider (most likely profit making) and not to their local NHS hospital. The result will be that the service in the NHS hospital will close (through lack of patients), and this may well have a knock-on effect of closing other, more complicated, services in the hospital that are cross-subsidised by the simpler services. (Poly Toynbee takes up this theme in her column in the Guardian today. An article that deserves a read.)

My message in my UK Uncut article was this. It's our NHS: Choose it, or lose it.

The problem is that this depends on patient choice, and patients are fickle. Let me give you an example. A few years ago I attended the AGM of the hospital local to me and there was a talk by their consultant eye surgeon. The talk was about Age-related macular degeneration. Until recently this was an untreatable condition: if you suffered the condition then you would go blind. Then it was discovered that people with one version of the condition (the so-called "wet" version) who were treated for bowel cancer found that the macular degeneration was halted. These patients were treated with an expensive drug called Avastin. Studies showed that when tiny doses of Avastin are used, the "wet" macular degeneration can be halted.

The surgeon told the AGM that such a dose of Avastin cost £1. The problem is that the drug company realised that patients were desperate to save their sight and would pay accordingly. The drug company chemically altered Avastin to remove the cancer treating property, but keeping the macular degeneration properties, and called this drug Lucentis. For no other reason than the fact that it would make them loads of money, the drug company priced Lucentis at £1000 per treatment. The surgeon told us that on average ten treatments were needed.

Avastin or Lucentis: £10 or £10,000? The surgeon said that all evidence showed that there was no difference between the two drugs other than the price. However, the drug company only applied for a licence for Lucentis to be used to treat "wet" age-related macular degeneration. Remember that we are told by the government that the NHS is horribly "wasteful"? It isn't. The surgeon told the AGM that when a patient is referred to his clinic it is explained to them that the licenced drug and the unlicenced drug are the same clinically, but there is a factor of a thousand in the cost of the drug. The hospital has to get the patient agreement to use the unlicenced drug and save the NHS (on average) £9,990 when saving their sight.

Half of patients choose the expensive drug even though it gave them no extra benefits.

Patients are fickle. Even when they are given all of the facts, there are some patients who think "if it costs a thousand times more, it must be better". I am sure the hospital did not mention rationing because they are professional. However, the half of patients who chose Lucentis also chose to deny another patient of a treatment that could improve their life, since there is a limited amount of money and money wasted on a drug that is priced to be a cash-cow is money that cannot be spent on other treatments.

In the future, when patients are given an AQP choice between a private hospital and an NHS hospital there will be some patients who will say (without any evidence to support their view): "the private hospital must be better". I want patients to defend our NHS, but I fear that too many will be enticed by irrational arguments to use non-NHS providers and this will result in our NHS hospitals closing.

Patients are fickle. This is why we will lose our NHS.

Update:
My thanks to @DrPanik on Twitter for this link to the New York Times describing the Avastin/Lucentis issue in the US.

Sunday, 2 October 2011

Hospital Closures and Catchment Areas

If patients behaved as consumers there would be no such thing as distinct "hospital catchment areas" because a patient would treat all hospitals in England as a candidate for their choice and consequently each hospital would have a "catchment area" of England. However, we know that patients do not want choice: they just want to use their local hospital. The most rabid governmental promoters of competition, the Cooperation [sic] and Competition Panel, say "on average patients travel around 12km to their chosen provider", the "chosen provider" is quite clearly a local provider. So hospital catchment areas are important.

Health Service Journal and the Financial Times have recently come out with lists of hospital trusts at financial risk. HSJ came up with a list of 22 trusts where their PFI payments are so large that they are unlikely to be able to meet the financial criteria required to be authorised as a Foundation Trust. The Financial Times list 17 trusts where their level of historical debt (which includes PFI) threaten their ability to be authorised as Foundation Trusts. There is some overlap between the two.

HSJ-22
Mid Yorkshire Hospitals
North Cumbria University Hospitals
St Helens and Knowsley
Sandwell and West Birmingham
University Hospitals Coventry and Warwickshire
Hereford Hospitals
Walsall Hospitals
University Hospital of North Staffordshire
Worcester Acute Hospitals
Mid Essex Hospital
Barts and the London
Barking, Havering and Redbridge University Hospitals
South London Healthcare
West Middlesex University Hospital
North Middlesex
Royal National Orthopaedic Hospital
Dartford and Gravesham
Maidstone and Tunbridge Wells
Buckinghamshire Hospitals
Portsmouth Hospitals
Oxford Radcliffe (+ Nuffield Orthopaedic Centre)
North Bristol

FT-17 
Mid Yorkshire Hospitals
North Cumbria University Hospitals
Trafford Healthcare
Hinchingbrooke Healthcare
North Bristol
Royal United Hospital Bath
Winchester and Eastleigh Healthcare
Heatherwood and Wexham Park Hospitals
Buckinghamshire Healthcare
Surrey and Sussex Healthcare
Royal Cornwall Hospitals
North West London Hospitals
West Middlesex University Hospital
St George's Healthcare
Whipps Cross University Hospital
Barking, Havering and Redbridge University Hospitals
South London Healthcare


In the original Bill the government said that if a trust is not a Foundation Trust by April 2014 it would cease to exist (meaning, it would have to merge with an existing FT, or close). Such a pronouncement was simply bonkers: there just wasn't enough time to change the finances of trusts with extremely large debts. Lansley stuck to the ludicrous deadline until the Future Forum made it clear how daft this deadline is. The deadline has now been moved to April 2016 and there is talk of it being pushed further into the future.

Politically it was bonkers too because a deadline of April 2014 would have meant that the government would go into the next election under the shadow of closing hospitals. Voters like hospitals and it is a brave politician that says that an NHS hospital must close. So there is an important political aspect too. Last December I pointed out that Labour and Liberal Democrat areas have a higher number of Foundation Trusts than Conservative areas. Foundation Trusts in general are the hospital trusts with better finances, so my limited analysis from last year showed that Conservative and Liberal Democrat MPs would be more at risk than Labour MPs seeking re-election.

Since last December I have been working on this political aspect, but it is not easy. One way to look at the issue is to look at the constituency where the trust is located. However, since the average constituency size is about 70k and even a small district general hospital will cover a population of several hundred thousand, it is clear that more than one constituency will be affected by the financial issues at a single trust. There is also the fact that in urban areas the catchment of hospitals overlap, so in the overlapping areas (where patients have two or more hospitals that they can regard as "local") the poor finances of one hospital will have a lesser effect. Clearly, any analysis means taking into account several constituencies around the trust and making estimates to "weight" the effect of poor finances.

Even so, in June I created the following spreadsheet to try and analyse the political effect of hospital finances. This is an extract because I collated more information but I could not come up with a good conclusion from the data. If you take a figure of around 5% as a "marginal" then the figures (for the combined HSJ-22 and FT-17 list) show that three Labour marginals and five Conservative marginals are affected. If we assume the campaigning in these marginals will target the Coalition (and increase the Labour vote) then these hospital trusts will only affect five seats, and of these only two are where Labour came second (and could take the seat). I rejected this analysis because it is far too simplistic to assume that only one seat would be affected by the local trust's finances.

Over the last few months I have tried to get an idea of the catchment areas of trusts. It is not an easy thing to do. Some trusts list in their annual reports the populations they cover; some trusts list this in their descriptions on the NHS Choices and some list it in their descriptions on the Dr Foster Intelligence website. The problem is that not all trusts do this, so if you use data from these sources you have to do some guess work.

A better way to determine the catchment area is to look at the home addresses of the patients who use a hospital. Such information is collated by the Hospital Episode Statistics Online website. Home addresses are personal and it would not be ethical for this information to be made public. However, it is possible to convert a postcode into a local authority election ward and since each ward is about 10k - 15k such data will not have patient identification values but can still be used to determine catchment areas. Unfortunately HES Online do not provide this data by default, but can provide it on request (for a fee).

This is what the South West Public Health Observatory have done. They have analysed HES data which includes the home address of the patient and produced a series of maps with electoral wards colour coded according to the number of patients who use the hospital. Take for example North Bristol NHS Trust. This is on both the HSJ-22 and FT-17 lists. The SWPHO gives the following map for the catchment area (I have provided an extract to conserve space).


The darker the blue shading, the more patients use the trust (the circles also indicate the number of patients). If we ignore the cyan areas (since some patients choose to go to other hospitals in these areas) and concentrate on the three shades of blue, we can see that patients come from seven 2010 constituencies and partially from another constituency. These constituencies are:

Bristol East (Labour, majority: 8.3%, 3,722)
Bristol South (Labour, majority: 9.8%, 4,734)Bristol West (LD, majority: 20.5%, 11,366)
Thornbury and Yate (LD, majority: 14.8%, 7,116)
Bristol North West (Conservative, majority: 6.5%, 3,274)
Filton and Bradley Stoke (Conservative, majority: 14.3%, 6,914)

Kingswood (Conservative, majority: 5.1%, 2,445)
North Somerset - partially (Conservative, majority: 13.6%, 7,862)

If we use the simplistic analysis of looking at the constituency where the trust is located then only Bristol North West would be at risk. However, widening out the analysis to include neighbouring constituencies where many patients live, the figures show that if there is a backlash against the Coalition parties due to the situation at North Bristol NHS Trust then at least two Conservative seats (Bristol North West and Kingswood) would be affected.

Saddly, other Public Health Observatories have not carried out the same analysis (or if they have, they do not make it publicly available). So to do a complete analysis of the effects of the HSJ-22 and FT-17 work will need to be done using HES data to map the catchment areas of these trusts.

Catchment areas are important.

MHP is a consultancy agency that have recently got some publicity over an article they wrote about the political aspect of the financial situation of trusts using the new constituency boundaries. Unfortunately they have rather lazily taken the approach of looking at the constituencies where the trusts are locate (an approach which I rejected - see above). Their "analysis" that caused a bit of a stir amongst the health policy twitterati says
"New research reveals that 21 struggling NHS trusts will be located in marginal constituencies at the next election following a review of constituency boundaries. Of these, 12 are located in ‘super-marginals’ with a notional majority of less than 1,000 after proposed boundary changes come into effect."
I think that this seriously under-estimates the effect of the finances of these trusts: using the constituency where the trust's registered address is located is a poor method.

So why haven't I done a more complete analysis? Money. Currently I am unemployed and I cannot afford to pay for the data. A tailor made dataset from HES Online that lists the patients using a hospital broken down into the wards where they live will cost between £348 and £773. I do not have that sort of money to spend. Also, the analysis will take time and if I get offered a job I will stop that work immediately. If someone is willing to pay me, say, a month's work (plus the expenses of getting the HES data) then I am willing and able to do the work.

I am surprised that MHP didn't do this work correctly, since their analysis shows that they really do not understand catchment areas of hospitals.

Saturday, 1 October 2011

Charidee

What are charities, the "voluntary sector", the "third sector"?

My definition of a charity is an organisation that has a social purpose not already provided by the state. Charities campaign and they provide support. These two aspects of charities are vital. And it is vital that they do these independent of the government. (Hence why the term Non Government Organisation is used for many charities.)

But should a charity provide services?

Support and campaigning are services, but should they provide services that are already (or should be) provided by the state? In my opinion, they should not. If charities provide services how can they continue to provide support for service users? How can they campaign on behalf of service users? They cannot, because they will be campaigning against themselves and supporting service users against themselves. There is a huge conflict of interest that no one seems to have noticed. Once a charity provides a service, it cannot support the people using that service. The only solution is for someone else to create a charity to support service users who are using a service provided by another charity. Madness!

Sadly, some charities seem to have decided that they are more than they should be. At the Labour party conference this week I attended a fringe meeting hosted by two charities, Rethink and Age UK. These charities described the Health and Social Care Bill as an "opportunity". They do not see the Bill as a danger, a Bill that will fragment the NHS. In fact, I got the impression that they regarded the NHS as the "problem", and themselves as the only "solution".

There is very little difference between such charities and the private sector. Indeed, such charities are run as if they are businesses, with high paid executives, plush offices and extensive marketing departments. The only difference between such charities and private sector companies are that the profits in the former are recycled back into the organisation and in the latter profits are distributed to the shareholders as dividends.

There is very little that is "voluntary" about the "voluntary sector". In most charities, the majority (and probably all) of the staff are employed. In some cases I would prefer a private sector company to provide a public service because at least with a private company there is accountability to the shareholders. With a charity the accountability is to the trustees, but who are they? Often no one knows who the trustees are, or how they get to be appointed.

(Not all charities are bad. Some are excellent and campaign for, and provide support for very vulnerable people. Often they do so with very little administrative costs. However, this is not typical of the "third sector", it is filling with organisations that are simply businesses with little or no accountability.)

So when someone talks to you about charities providing public services, unblinker yourself and see them for what they are: non-public, non-accountable private organisations.

Thursday, 22 September 2011

Designer Insulin

The BBC report on a BMJ article about analogue insulins, saying:

The NHS could have saved £625m over 10 years if the older types of insulin recommended in guidelines had been prescribed, claim UK researchers.
Apparently, if the NHS had used the current NICE guidelines fewer diabetics would have been prescribed analogue insulin and would be prescribed human insulin instead. Analogue insulin cost three times as much as the equivalent human insulin.

I take the cheaper human insulin. When I was prescribed analogue insulin there was very little consultation, very few checks, the doctor simply said that "it will be better for you". This happened twice (for my basal and short acting insulin). Each time I used it for two years, found that it wasn't "better for me" and went back to the human insulin. At this point there was no attempt from the doctor to find out why I had chosen to reject the analogue insulin, so I assume they really didn't mind one way or the other.

So basically I had had two years taking an insulin that neither I, nor the doctor thought was "better" for me. So basically I agree with the conclusion that it was a waste of money (and the large effort by me trying to get a good blood sugar).

Campaigning and Fixed Term Parliaments

It is now law that UK Parliaments must last exactly 5 years. Get out your diaries for the next 50 years and mark the first Thursday in May in 2015, 2020, 2025... to be the day of the General Election. Since we know when the election will be, MPs will be able to schedule their canvassing. It is likely that those MPs who have a small majority will want to canvas for the optimum amount of time before the election to ensure they get re-elected.

Since voters have a short memory it means that once an MP is elected s/he can safely ignore the electorate for the majority of the term as long as they are seen everywhere for roughly a year before the election (and hence voters will not remember that they've been ignored for four years). MPs are paid a salary of about £64k and they do not have to attend Parliament: they do not have to take part in committees nor debates. The only job performance evaluation is on election day, and since elections are more a case of a popularity contest for the candidate (and/or their party leader) their performance in Parliament is largely irrelevant.

Since an MP is the representative of a constituency s/he is expected to do constituency work, but how do you know whether their presence in the constituency is electioneering, or constituency work? This means that an MP can legitimately spend a year canvassing and will be paid to do it.

Love it or loath it, the old system kept MPs on their toes. They did not know when the election would be. Consequently the electioneering occurred during the few weeks between the Prime Minister calling the election and the election day. That is all the time we have to put up with canvassing politician! Under fixed term Parliaments we will have to put up with canvassing politicians for (most likely) eight months. It works like this. The MP will finish a Parliamentary session in July the year before the election and then have a long holiday until September. At that point the public will see politicians on the TV and hence your local MP will have to be seen. For MPs with small majorities this is the time that the electioneering will start.

Rather than spend their time in London, they will spend it in their constituency canvassing (the public pays for them to have a home there). Since they will only need to return to vote in the cases when the vote is tight, that means they will be able to canvas every day until the following May. This gives them 8 months (with one day a week off, that means 200 days). A constituency will be about 18,000 homes. It is easily possible for an MP to visit 18k/200 or 90 houses a day (more likely they will avoid the areas where they are unlikely to get any votes, or areas where they can rely on the vote, which will cut the canvassing down considerably).

All of this means that the incumbent has a huge advantage. They will be paid to canvas and they will have a constituency base paid for. This means they can make sure that they can target swing voters to ensure their re-election.

Other candidates do not have this advantage. If they do not live in the constituency they will have the cost and disruption of buying or renting a home in the constituency. If the candidates is employed they will have to ensure that they work near the constituency (or change job), and they will then have to do their canvassing after a full day's work. This will mean that a candidate will be restricted in the number of homes they could canvas. The only people able to match the canvassing ability of an incumbent MP is someone with an independent income that they can use to finance their campaign. In other words: wealthy people.

The effect of fixed term parliaments is that it will favour the incumbent, and the only people who could challenge a sitting MP is someone who has a pot of cash that they can afford to spend on their campaign. Consequently, the House of Commons will get less representative as the only people able to campaign are the very rich.

Labour have a huge task to gain a majority at the next election. I estimate that Labour would need something like a 12% swing - compare this with the 8.8% swing that Tony Blair got in 1997.

For Refounding Labour I submitted the following idea. The Labour party should select its candidates early, preferably two years before the election (we know when the election will be!) The candidate will then be paid by the Labour party a living wage. say £18,000. The candidate then has the money to secure (rent) accommodation in the constituency and will be able to work full time canvassing. Since this is a wage, it should ensure that people without an independent income will be attracted to stand as a candidate. This should raise the number of women and BAME candidates and make the use of all women lists unnecessary.

A paid candidate will have two years to be seen as being a community leader, getting involved in local issues and hopefully getting results. This raises the profile of Labour in the area (which will hopefully have an effect on local authority elections) and will actually benefit the area. The ultimate result, of course, is that the area will get a Labour MP. If the candidate is elected, they will be an MP with a salary of £64k. This means (and only if they become an MP) they could pay back the money they were paid (say £12k a year, this means the "loan" will be repaid in three years). But there is an important point: they only pay back this money if they become the MP. If the candidate is not successful, they will not have to pay back the money. Since being a candidate should be treated as being a job (performance managed by the local constituency party who will feedback to the central party) the candidate must work as a full time campaigner. Since the candidate knows that they will be paid for the canvassing (and only repay when they become an MP and are earning 3.5 times more) it will not be seen as being a financial drain to be a candidate. The result is that it is more likely that there will be candidates from all walks of life, not just those who have an independent income.

The big issue is if a candidate fails to be elected. I suggest that existing Labour MPs pay for those paid candidates who are not successful. The 240 or so current Labour MPs standing for re-election at the 2015 election will have the advantage of being the incumbent, and so will be a paid canvasser as explained above. This means that there is no need to pay them a candidate's wage. To get a majority of 300 at the next election Labour would need approximately 60 more seats, so it makes sense to target the 100-most marginal constituencies. The money for these 100 candidates would amount to £3.6m and this could be raised by a 7% levy on all the Labour MPs from this point until the 2015 election (assuming MP salary of £64k, 3.5 years to the election). After the next election all MPs could then pay a levy of 4.3% every year (the 60 new MPs would pay this for this after paying off their candidate wage) which would fund 100 waged campaigners for the last two years of the parliament and this could be split between campaigners supporting the 50 Labour MPs with the smallest majority and the 50 target marginal seats.